Summit Capital Boosts NPS by 35% with Targeted Client Surveys

Summit Capital Boosts NPS by 35% with Targeted Client Surveys

Executive Summary

Summit Capital, a growing RIA managing over $500 million in assets, struggled to consistently gauge client satisfaction and proactively address concerns, leading to potential client attrition. To combat this, David Park, Head of Client Experience, implemented a targeted Net Promoter Score (NPS) survey program utilizing Qualtrics. This initiative, coupled with strategic follow-up based on survey responses, resulted in a 35% increase in Summit Capital's NPS, demonstrating a significant improvement in client loyalty and positive referrals.

The Challenge

Summit Capital prided itself on delivering personalized financial advice and comprehensive wealth management services. However, as the firm grew and its client base expanded, maintaining a pulse on client sentiment became increasingly challenging. Informal feedback mechanisms, like ad-hoc phone calls and annual portfolio reviews, proved insufficient for identifying and addressing emerging concerns.

Specifically, Summit Capital faced the following challenges:

• Lack of Proactive Feedback: The firm primarily relied on clients to initiate complaints or share concerns. This reactive approach meant that problems often went unaddressed until they escalated, potentially leading to client dissatisfaction and attrition. For example, a client with a $1.5 million portfolio felt their risk tolerance wasn't adequately considered during a recent market downturn, but only voiced their concerns after several weeks of anxiety.
• Inconsistent Service Experience: With multiple advisors managing client relationships, the quality and consistency of service varied. Some advisors were excellent at proactive communication, while others struggled to maintain regular contact. This inconsistency impacted client satisfaction and potentially increased the risk of clients seeking alternative advisory services. They estimated a potential loss of $25 million AUM due to inconsistent communication alone.
• Missed Opportunities for Improvement: Without a systematic method for collecting and analyzing client feedback, Summit Capital missed opportunities to identify areas for improvement and enhance its service offerings. For instance, a post-tax season survey revealed that a significant number of clients found the tax reporting process confusing, but this information was not readily available to drive process improvements.
• Difficulty Identifying At-Risk Clients: Without a clear understanding of client sentiment, Summit Capital struggled to identify clients who were at risk of leaving. This made it difficult to proactively address their concerns and retain their business. The firm estimated that they were losing 2% of their client base annually due to preventable dissatisfaction, equating to roughly $10 million AUM per year.
• Limited Data-Driven Decision Making: Decisions on service enhancements and operational improvements were often based on anecdotal evidence rather than concrete data. This made it difficult to prioritize initiatives and measure the effectiveness of changes. They realized that a data-driven method could help focus on the most impactful changes, potentially improving client retention by 1% and adding $5 million to AUM.

The Approach

David Park recognized that a more systematic and data-driven approach was needed to understand client sentiment and proactively address concerns. He spearheaded the implementation of a targeted NPS survey program, designed to gather regular feedback and identify areas for improvement.

The core elements of the approach were:

1. Strategic Segmentation: Clients were segmented based on factors such as assets under management (AUM), account type (e.g., retirement, taxable), and advisor relationship tenure. This segmentation allowed for targeted surveys and tailored follow-up strategies. Clients with over $1 million AUM and those with newer advisor relationships (less than 1 year) were flagged as high-priority for increased attention.
2. NPS Survey Implementation: A concise NPS survey was deployed quarterly to a representative sample of clients within each segment. The survey included the standard NPS question ("On a scale of 0 to 10, how likely are you to recommend Summit Capital to a friend or colleague?") along with a few open-ended questions to gather qualitative feedback, like "What is the primary reason for your score?" and "What could we do to improve your experience?".
3. Automated Follow-Up: Based on the NPS score, automated follow-up sequences were triggered. Promoters (scores of 9-10) received a thank-you email encouraging them to leave a review on a platform like Google Reviews or WealthManagement.com. Passives (scores of 7-8) received a personalized email acknowledging their feedback and asking for more specific input on areas for improvement. Detractors (scores of 0-6) were immediately contacted by their advisor or a member of the client service team to understand their concerns and resolve any issues.
4. Personalized Action Plans: Advisors were trained to use the feedback from the NPS surveys to develop personalized action plans for each client. This included addressing specific concerns, improving communication frequency, and tailoring investment strategies to meet individual needs. For example, a client who expressed dissatisfaction with their portfolio performance was offered a complimentary portfolio review and an opportunity to discuss alternative investment strategies.
5. Closed-Loop Feedback: The firm implemented a closed-loop feedback process, ensuring that all client feedback was acknowledged, addressed, and documented. This process helped to build trust and demonstrate a commitment to continuous improvement. A tracking system was implemented to monitor the resolution of client concerns and ensure that no feedback was overlooked.
6. Integration with CRM: The NPS survey data was integrated with the firm's existing Client Relationship Management (CRM) system, providing advisors with a holistic view of each client's relationship with Summit Capital. This integration enabled advisors to proactively identify and address potential issues before they escalated.

Technical Implementation

The success of Summit Capital's NPS survey program hinged on a robust technical infrastructure and seamless integration with existing systems.

• Survey Platform: Qualtrics was selected as the survey platform due to its advanced features, user-friendly interface, and robust integration capabilities. Qualtrics allowed for easy survey creation, automated distribution, data analysis, and reporting. The platform also offered features such as skip logic and branching, which allowed for customized survey experiences based on client responses.
• CRM Integration: Qualtrics was integrated with Summit Capital's CRM system (Salesforce Financial Services Cloud) using the Qualtrics API. This integration allowed for the automated transfer of NPS survey data into the CRM system, providing advisors with a comprehensive view of each client's relationship with the firm. The integration also enabled the automated triggering of follow-up tasks based on NPS scores.
• Segmentation Logic: The segmentation of clients was automated within the CRM system. Rules were created to automatically categorize clients based on AUM, account type, and advisor relationship tenure. This ensured that the right surveys were sent to the right clients at the right time.
• Automated Email Sequences: Automated email sequences were created within Qualtrics to trigger personalized follow-up emails based on NPS scores. These email sequences were designed to be highly engaging and informative, providing clients with clear instructions on how to provide additional feedback or resolve their concerns.
• Data Analysis and Reporting: Qualtrics provided a range of data analysis and reporting tools that allowed Summit Capital to track NPS scores over time, identify trends, and measure the effectiveness of the survey program. The firm also created custom dashboards within Qualtrics to provide advisors with real-time insights into client sentiment. To quantify the impact, the firm tracked the correlation between NPS scores and client retention rates, using regression analysis to determine the statistical significance of the relationship.

The NPS calculation was performed using the standard formula:

NPS = % of Promoters (score 9-10) - % of Detractors (score 0-6)

The statistical significance of the NPS increase was evaluated using a two-tailed t-test, comparing the NPS scores before and after the implementation of the targeted survey program. A p-value of less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant.

Results & ROI

The implementation of the targeted NPS survey program yielded significant positive results for Summit Capital.

• NPS Improvement: Summit Capital's Net Promoter Score increased by 35% within the first year of implementation, moving from 40 to 54. This increase demonstrated a significant improvement in client satisfaction and loyalty.
• Client Retention: Client retention rates increased by 1.5% following the implementation of the survey program. This resulted in a reduction in client attrition and a corresponding increase in AUM. Based on an average client portfolio size of $750,000, this 1.5% increase translates to approximately $5.6 million in retained AUM.
• Positive Referrals: The increase in NPS led to a surge in positive referrals. The firm saw a 20% increase in new client referrals from existing clients, contributing to the growth of its client base. These referrals resulted in an additional $8 million in new AUM within the first year.
• Improved Client Communication: The targeted survey program provided advisors with valuable insights into client needs and preferences. This enabled advisors to improve their communication frequency and tailor their advice to meet individual client requirements.
• Enhanced Service Offerings: The feedback gathered through the NPS surveys helped Summit Capital identify areas for improvement and enhance its service offerings. For example, based on client feedback, the firm simplified its tax reporting process and introduced new investment strategies tailored to specific client needs. This resulted in increased client satisfaction and loyalty.
• Financial Impact: The increased retention (+$5.6M AUM) plus the AUM from referrals (+$8M AUM) totaled $13.6M. At Summit Capital's average advisory fee of 1%, the NPS survey program generated an additional $136,000 in revenue.

Key Takeaways

For other RIAs and wealth managers looking to improve client satisfaction and drive growth, Summit Capital's experience offers several key takeaways:

1. Implement a Systematic Feedback Mechanism: Don't rely solely on ad-hoc feedback. Implement a structured system for gathering regular client feedback, such as NPS surveys or client satisfaction surveys.
2. Segment Your Client Base: Tailor your survey approach and follow-up strategies based on client segments. This allows you to address specific needs and concerns more effectively.
3. Act on Feedback: Don't just collect data; act on it. Develop personalized action plans based on client feedback and implement a closed-loop feedback process to ensure that all concerns are addressed.
4. Integrate with Existing Systems: Integrate your survey platform with your CRM system to provide advisors with a holistic view of each client's relationship with the firm.
5. Communicate Proactively: Regularly communicate with clients, even if they don't provide negative feedback. This helps to build trust and demonstrate a commitment to providing excellent service.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors identify at-risk clients, personalize investment strategies, and automate key workflows. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.