$150K Tax Savings: Value-Added Service Enhances Client Loyalty

$150K Tax Savings: Value-Added Service Enhances Client Loyalty

Executive Summary

Montgomery Retirement Solutions, a leading RIA, faced the challenge of differentiating its services in a competitive market. They sought a way to provide demonstrable value beyond traditional investment management. By partnering with a CPA to offer complimentary preliminary tax reviews, Montgomery Retirement Solutions identified an average of $150,000 in potential tax savings per participating client, leading to increased client loyalty and deeper relationships.

The Challenge

In today's crowded financial advisory landscape, Montgomery Retirement Solutions understood that delivering superior investment returns alone wasn't enough to guarantee client retention and attract new business. Many of their clients, high-net-worth individuals nearing or already in retirement, were primarily concerned with minimizing their tax burden and maximizing their after-tax income.

While Montgomery Retirement Solutions offered basic tax-related advice as part of their financial planning services, they recognized an opportunity to provide a more comprehensive and proactive approach. For example, consider Mrs. Davison, a long-term client with a portfolio valued at $2 million. While her portfolio had seen an average annual return of 8%, she was frustrated that approximately 30% of those gains were being eaten up by taxes. This amounted to roughly $48,000 in annual taxes on investment gains alone. She felt this significantly hampered her ability to fully enjoy her retirement income.

Another challenge was the increasing complexity of tax laws. Changes in legislation, such as those related to qualified business income (QBI) deductions or the treatment of capital gains, often went unnoticed by clients until tax season, leaving them with little time to make adjustments and potentially miss out on significant savings opportunities. Furthermore, many clients, used to handling their own taxes, often left money on the table. It became apparent that a reactive approach to tax planning was not only insufficient but also a potential point of dissatisfaction for clients. Montgomery Retirement Solutions needed a way to proactively address these tax-related concerns and demonstrate tangible value beyond simply managing investments. Their goal was to go beyond providing generic tax advice and deliver concrete strategies to minimize their clients' tax liabilities, ultimately enhancing client loyalty and solidifying their position as trusted financial partners. This required a strategic shift to offering a value-added service that demonstrably improved clients' financial well-being beyond investment returns.

The Approach

Montgomery Retirement Solutions adopted a proactive and client-centric approach by offering complimentary preliminary tax reviews to their existing client base. This service was designed to identify potential tax savings opportunities before the traditional tax season, allowing clients ample time to implement strategies and minimize their tax burden.

The strategic decision-making process involved the following steps:

1. Partner Selection: They partnered with a reputable and experienced Certified Public Accountant (CPA) firm specializing in high-net-worth individuals. This partnership was crucial to ensuring the accuracy and expertise of the tax reviews. The CPA firm possessed in-depth knowledge of complex tax laws and strategies, providing a level of expertise that Montgomery Retirement Solutions lacked internally.

2. Service Design: The complimentary tax review was structured as a comprehensive analysis of the client's prior year's tax return, along with a review of their current financial situation and future goals. The review focused on identifying opportunities for tax deductions, credits, and other tax-saving strategies.

3. Client Communication: Montgomery Retirement Solutions proactively reached out to their existing clients, explaining the benefits of the complimentary tax review and emphasizing the potential for significant tax savings. They highlighted the proactive nature of the service and its potential to improve their overall financial well-being.

4. Data Collection & Security: To facilitate the tax review process, Montgomery Retirement Solutions developed a secure system for collecting and sharing client tax data with the partnered CPA firm. This system was designed to comply with all relevant privacy regulations and protect client confidentiality.

5. Review & Recommendations: The CPA firm conducted the tax review and prepared a detailed report outlining potential tax savings opportunities, along with specific recommendations for implementing those strategies.

6. Client Consultation: Montgomery Retirement Solutions then met with the clients to discuss the findings of the tax review and help them understand the recommendations. They worked with the clients to develop a plan for implementing the recommended strategies, taking into account their individual financial goals and circumstances.

This approach was not just about providing tax advice; it was about building deeper relationships with clients by demonstrating a commitment to their overall financial well-being and proactively seeking opportunities to improve their financial outcomes. It also allowed Montgomery Retirement Solutions to position themselves as a true partner, going beyond simply managing investments to providing comprehensive financial planning and tax optimization services. The strategic emphasis was placed on building trust and client satisfaction, resulting in increased client loyalty and reduced attrition.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation of the tax review service prioritized data security and efficiency, ensuring a seamless and compliant process. Here's a breakdown of the key elements:

1. Secure Data Transfer: Client tax data, including sensitive information such as Social Security numbers, income statements, and investment details, was securely transferred to the partnered CPA firm using a Secure File Transfer Protocol (SFTP) server. This SFTP server employed strong encryption protocols to protect the data during transmission and storage, minimizing the risk of unauthorized access.

2. Data Segmentation & Anonymization (Where Applicable): While complete anonymization was not possible due to the nature of tax data, efforts were made to segment and minimize the amount of directly identifiable information accessed by specific CPA team members based on their role in the review process.

3. Compliance & Audit Trail: The entire process was designed to comply with relevant privacy regulations, including the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA) and state-specific data privacy laws. An audit trail was maintained to track all data access and modifications, providing a record of who accessed what information and when.

4. Tax Software Integration: The CPA firm utilized professional tax software, such as UltraTax CS or ProSeries, to analyze the client's tax data and identify potential tax savings opportunities. This software incorporated the latest tax laws and regulations, ensuring the accuracy of the review. The data was manually entered into the software or imported via compatible file formats (e.g., CSV, TXT) depending on the source and client preference for data delivery.

5. Tax Planning Calculations: The tax review process involved complex calculations to determine the potential tax savings from various strategies. This included analyzing opportunities for:

   • Capital Loss Harvesting: Identifying opportunities to offset capital gains with capital losses to reduce taxable income. For example, if a client had $50,000 in capital gains, strategically selling underperforming assets to realize a $3,000 capital loss could reduce their taxable capital gains to $47,000.

   • Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction: Determining eligibility for the QBI deduction, which allows eligible taxpayers to deduct up to 20% of their qualified business income. This required analyzing the client's business income, W-2 wages, and unadjusted basis immediately after acquisition (UBIA) of qualified property.

   • Retirement Account Optimization: Analyzing strategies for maximizing contributions to tax-advantaged retirement accounts, such as 401(k)s and IRAs, to reduce taxable income. This included evaluating the potential benefits of Roth conversions and backdoor Roth IRAs.

   • Charitable Contribution Strategies: Exploring opportunities for maximizing charitable deductions, such as donating appreciated stock or establishing a donor-advised fund. The calculation would involve comparing the tax benefits of different donation methods and strategies.

   • Itemized Deductions vs. Standard Deduction: Performing a thorough analysis of whether itemized deductions, such as medical expenses, mortgage interest, and state and local taxes, exceeded the standard deduction, allowing the client to reduce their taxable income.

6. Reporting: The findings of the tax review were compiled into a comprehensive report, including a summary of potential tax savings, specific recommendations for implementing those strategies, and supporting documentation. This report was delivered to Montgomery Retirement Solutions via a secure portal for review and subsequent discussion with the client.

By implementing these technical measures, Montgomery Retirement Solutions ensured the security and accuracy of the tax review service, providing clients with valuable insights and maximizing their potential tax savings.

Results & ROI

The implementation of the complimentary tax review service yielded significant positive results for both Montgomery Retirement Solutions and their clients.

• Average Tax Savings: On average, the tax review service identified approximately $150,000 in potential tax savings per client who participated. This was calculated based on a sample of 50 client reviews conducted in the first year of the program. The savings ranged from $50,000 to $350,000, depending on the client's individual circumstances and financial complexity.

• Client Retention Rate: Montgomery Retirement Solutions experienced a 15% increase in client retention rate among clients who participated in the tax review service. Prior to the program, their annual client attrition rate was approximately 8%. After implementing the tax review, the attrition rate for participating clients dropped to approximately 2%.

• Client Satisfaction Scores: Client satisfaction scores, measured through post-service surveys, increased by 20% among clients who received the tax review. Clients specifically cited the proactive and personalized nature of the service as key factors contributing to their increased satisfaction.

• New Client Acquisition: The tax review service also proved to be a valuable marketing tool, attracting new clients to Montgomery Retirement Solutions. The firm reported a 10% increase in new client acquisition as a direct result of referrals from satisfied clients who had benefited from the tax review service. The demonstrable value of the service, highlighted in client testimonials and marketing materials, resonated with prospective clients seeking comprehensive financial planning and tax optimization services.

• Increased Assets Under Management (AUM): While difficult to directly attribute, Montgomery Retirement Solutions experienced a noticeable increase in AUM from existing clients. The deepened trust and enhanced relationship stemming from the tax review program encouraged clients to consolidate more of their assets under Montgomery's management. It's estimated this accounted for a 5% increase in AUM from existing clients over the year following the implementation.

• Time Savings: The automation tools and streamlined data sharing process saved internal staff an estimated 40 hours per month that would otherwise be spent gathering and preparing client data for review. This freed up staff time to focus on other value-added services and client interactions.

The ROI of the tax review service was substantial, not only in terms of direct financial savings for clients but also in terms of increased client loyalty, improved client satisfaction, and new client acquisition for Montgomery Retirement Solutions. The service proved to be a valuable investment that enhanced the firm's reputation and strengthened its competitive position in the market.

Key Takeaways

Here are a few actionable insights for other RIAs considering implementing a similar strategy:

1. Proactive Service is Key: Clients highly value proactive services that address their specific financial needs. Go beyond routine portfolio management and identify opportunities to add tangible value.

2. Strategic Partnerships are Essential: Partnering with experts, such as CPAs, can significantly enhance your service offering and provide specialized expertise that you may lack internally. Ensure proper due diligence is conducted when choosing a partner.

3. Data Security is Paramount: When handling sensitive client data, prioritize data security and compliance with relevant privacy regulations. Implement robust security measures and establish clear protocols for data transfer and storage.

4. Communicate the Value Clearly: Effectively communicate the benefits of your value-added services to clients and prospects. Highlight the potential for significant savings and emphasize the proactive nature of your approach.

5. Measure and Track Results: Track key metrics, such as client retention rates, satisfaction scores, and new client acquisition, to measure the effectiveness of your value-added services and identify areas for improvement. Use feedback to refine the service.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors personalize client interactions and surface actionable insights to improve financial outcomes. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.