Quarterly Business Reviews Cut Client Churn by 10% - Lisa Tanaka
Executive Summary
Precision Financial Group was experiencing unacceptable client attrition due to a perceived lack of communication and personalized service. To combat this, Lisa Tanaka, a senior advisor, spearheaded the implementation of quarterly business reviews (QBRs) for all high-net-worth clients. This proactive approach, leveraging tools like Calendly, PowerPoint, and Wealthbox, resulted in a 10% reduction in client churn, an 8% increase in average client AUM, and a 15% improvement in client satisfaction.
The Challenge
Precision Financial Group, like many RIAs, faced the persistent challenge of client retention. While their investment performance was solid, the firm noticed a worrying trend: clients were leaving after an average of just 3 years. Exit interviews revealed a recurring theme: a perceived lack of proactive communication and a feeling that their individual financial goals weren't being regularly addressed.
Specifically, Precision Financial Group was losing approximately 15 clients annually from its high-net-worth segment (those with AUM exceeding $1 million). This represented roughly 5% of the firm's total high-net-worth client base and translated to a loss of approximately $15 million in AUM annually (assuming an average AUM of $1 million per departing client). Furthermore, the negative impact on the firm's reputation and the cost of acquiring new clients to replace those lost added significant pressure.
One particular case highlighted the issue. A client, Mr. and Mrs. Davis, with $2.5 million in AUM, decided to move their assets to a competing firm. They cited that while Precision Financial Group initially provided a detailed financial plan, subsequent check-ins were infrequent and felt more like generic performance updates rather than personalized consultations addressing their evolving retirement goals. They felt their concerns about healthcare costs in retirement, which had significantly increased, were not adequately addressed in their initial financial plan. This was a clear signal that the firm needed to proactively address clients' changing needs and priorities. This lack of tailored service and communication created a blind spot, increasing the risk of other clients feeling similarly neglected, and potentially leaving for a more attentive advisor. The financial impact of losing clients like the Davises was substantial, and it triggered the need to find a better method of client communications and engagement.
The Approach
Lisa Tanaka recognized that addressing the client attrition issue required a fundamental shift in how Precision Financial Group interacted with its high-net-worth clients. Her approach centered on implementing regular, structured quarterly business reviews (QBRs). These reviews were designed to be more than just performance updates; they were envisioned as opportunities for in-depth discussions about clients' financial goals, changing circumstances, and any necessary adjustments to their financial plans.
Lisa championed a proactive communication strategy. Instead of waiting for clients to reach out with concerns, the QBRs would initiate a dialogue, ensuring that clients felt heard and valued. The structure of each QBR was carefully planned and standardized to guarantee consistency and thoroughness.
First, Lisa implemented a three-week scheduling window at the end of each quarter, using Calendly to allow clients to easily book a convenient time slot. This minimized back-and-forth communication and empowered clients to take ownership of the process.
Second, a pre-QBR questionnaire was sent to clients a week before their scheduled review. This questionnaire asked targeted questions about any significant life events, changes in financial goals, or concerns they wanted to discuss. This information allowed Lisa and her team to prepare thoroughly for each meeting and tailor the discussion to the client's specific needs.
Third, each QBR followed a consistent agenda:
- Performance Review: A concise overview of the client's portfolio performance over the past quarter, highlighting key drivers of returns and addressing any underperformance.
- Goal Review: A discussion of the client's progress towards their financial goals (e.g., retirement, education funding, estate planning). This section was highly personalized, referencing the client's initial financial plan and any subsequent adjustments.
- Financial Planning Update: An opportunity to review and update the client's financial plan based on their current circumstances and goals. This could involve adjusting asset allocation, revising retirement projections, or exploring new investment opportunities.
- Action Items: A clear list of action items for both the advisor and the client, with specific deadlines. This ensured accountability and kept the client engaged in the financial planning process.
Finally, Lisa stressed the importance of documenting each QBR in Wealthbox CRM. This included a summary of the discussion, any agreed-upon action items, and any changes made to the client's financial plan. This centralized record-keeping ensured that all members of the team were aware of the client's current situation and needs.
Lisa also emphasized the importance of actively listening to clients during the QBRs and demonstrating empathy. She trained her team to ask open-ended questions, acknowledge clients' concerns, and provide clear, concise explanations of complex financial concepts. The goal was to build trust and rapport with clients, fostering a sense of partnership and collaboration.
Technical Implementation
The successful implementation of the QBR program relied on a combination of technology tools and a well-defined process.
- Scheduling: Calendly was used to automate the scheduling process. A branded Calendly page was created with specific time slots available for QBRs. A link to this page was included in the initial communication to clients, making it easy for them to book their review. Calendly automatically sent reminders to both the advisor and the client, minimizing the risk of missed appointments.
- Presentation: PowerPoint was used to create standardized QBR presentation templates. These templates included sections for performance review, goal review, financial planning update, and action items. The templates were customized for each client with their specific data and information, pulled directly from the portfolio management system. The performance review section included key performance indicators (KPIs) such as total return, benchmark comparison, and risk-adjusted return (Sharpe Ratio).
- CRM Integration: Wealthbox CRM served as the central repository for all client information and QBR documentation. Each QBR was documented as a note in the client's record, including a summary of the discussion, any agreed-upon action items, and a link to the presentation. Tasks were created in Wealthbox for any action items assigned to the advisor or the client, with specific due dates. The CRM also allowed Lisa to track the overall progress of the QBR program, monitoring the number of reviews completed, the average client satisfaction score, and the impact on client retention. A custom field was added to Wealthbox to track the date of the last QBR completed for each client. Reports were generated regularly to identify clients who were overdue for a review.
- Data Security: All client data was stored securely in accordance with industry best practices. Wealthbox is SOC 2 compliant and uses encryption to protect sensitive information. All QBR presentations were stored on a secure server with restricted access. The firm implemented a data security policy that outlined procedures for handling client data, including password management, data backup, and disaster recovery.
- Performance Calculations: Portfolio performance was calculated using time-weighted return (TWR) methodology, eliminating the impact of cash flows on performance. Benchmark comparisons were based on appropriate market indices (e.g., S&P 500, Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index) relevant to the client's asset allocation. Risk-adjusted return was calculated using the Sharpe Ratio, which measures the excess return over the risk-free rate per unit of risk (standard deviation). These calculations were included in the QBR presentation to provide clients with a clear and concise understanding of their portfolio performance.
Results & ROI
The implementation of quarterly business reviews yielded significant positive results for Precision Financial Group.
- Client Churn Reduction: The most significant outcome was a 10% reduction in client churn among high-net-worth clients. Prior to the QBR program, the firm was losing approximately 5% of its high-net-worth clients annually. After implementing the QBR program, this rate dropped to 4%. This translated to retaining approximately 3 additional high-net-worth clients per year, each with an average AUM of $1 million.
- Increased AUM: The average AUM per high-net-worth client increased by 8% within one year of implementing the QBR program. This was attributed to increased client confidence in the firm's services and a greater willingness to consolidate assets under management. This increase represented an additional $80,000 in AUM per client, on average.
- Improved Client Satisfaction: Client satisfaction scores, measured through post-QBR surveys, increased by 15%. Clients consistently rated the QBRs as valuable and appreciated the proactive communication and personalized service. The Net Promoter Score (NPS) increased from 60 to 75.
- Increased Referrals: An increase in referrals, with more existing clients recommending Precision Financial Group to their friends and family. The number of new client onboarding from referrals increased by 20% year-over-year after the first year of implementing QBRs.
- Increased Client Engagement: Clients who actively participated in QBRs demonstrated a greater understanding of their financial plans and were more likely to implement the recommended strategies. This led to improved outcomes in areas such as retirement savings, tax planning, and estate planning.
In terms of financial impact, the reduction in client churn and the increase in average AUM resulted in a significant increase in revenue for Precision Financial Group. Based on an average advisory fee of 1% of AUM, the firm realized an estimated $30,000 of additional revenue per year per retained client, leading to hundreds of thousands of dollars in incremental revenue. The increase in referrals also contributed to higher revenue and faster growth.
Key Takeaways
Here are a few actionable insights that other financial advisors can learn from Lisa Tanaka's successful implementation of quarterly business reviews:
- Proactive Communication is Key: Don't wait for clients to reach out with concerns. Initiate regular, structured communication to demonstrate your commitment to their financial well-being.
- Personalize the Experience: Tailor each review to the client's specific goals, circumstances, and concerns. Use pre-QBR questionnaires to gather relevant information and prepare thoroughly.
- Leverage Technology: Utilize tools like Calendly, PowerPoint, and CRM to streamline the QBR process and improve efficiency. Automate scheduling, create standardized presentations, and document all interactions in a central repository.
- Focus on Building Relationships: Use QBRs as an opportunity to build trust and rapport with clients. Actively listen to their concerns, provide clear and concise explanations, and demonstrate empathy.
- Track Results and Iterate: Monitor the impact of your QBR program on key metrics such as client churn, AUM, and client satisfaction. Use the data to identify areas for improvement and continuously refine your approach.
About Golden Door Asset
Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors proactively identify client needs, personalize their advice, and automate key workflows. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.