Building Community: 35% Increase in Next-Gen Referrals

Building Community: 35% Increase in Next-Gen Referrals

Executive Summary

Santos Financial faced challenges in attracting and retaining next-generation clients, relying on traditional marketing methods that proved ineffective. To address this, Dr. Santos launched a curated online community focused on financial literacy and millennial values, fostering engagement and trust through consistent, valuable content. As a result, referrals from next-generation clients increased by 35% within six months, demonstrating the community's positive impact on client acquisition.

The Challenge

Santos Financial, a thriving RIA practice managing over $250 million in assets, recognized a growing problem: a lack of engagement with the next generation of potential clients – millennials and Gen Z. Dr. Santos, the firm's founder, observed that the average age of their client base was steadily increasing, raising concerns about long-term sustainability and generational wealth transfer.

Traditional marketing methods, such as newspaper ads and direct mail campaigns, yielded minimal results when targeting younger demographics. A recent $10,000 direct mail campaign targeting individuals aged 25-40 resulted in only five initial consultations, converting into just one new client with approximately $75,000 in managed assets. This translated to a customer acquisition cost of $10,000 per client, far exceeding industry benchmarks and highlighting the ineffectiveness of these approaches.

Furthermore, the firm’s existing digital presence, a static website and infrequent email newsletter, failed to resonate with younger audiences accustomed to interactive and personalized experiences. Social media accounts, updated sporadically, lacked a clear strategy and failed to cultivate meaningful engagement. The firm's client retention rate for younger clients (under 40) was only 78% compared to 92% for older demographics, signifying a churn rate problem that needed immediate attention. This churn translated into an estimated loss of $3 million in assets under management annually. The core challenge lay in understanding and connecting with the values and priorities of the next-generation investor, which significantly differed from their older counterparts. Specifically, the lack of relevant, engaging content was identified as the primary reason for low conversion and high churn.

The Approach

Dr. Santos decided to pivot from traditional marketing towards a community-driven approach. This involved creating a curated online space specifically designed to resonate with the values and interests of millennial and Gen Z investors. The strategy centered around three key pillars:

1. Content Pillars Aligned with Next-Gen Values: Recognizing that younger investors prioritize financial literacy, ethical investing, and achieving life goals beyond pure financial gain, Dr. Santos developed content pillars focusing on:

• Financial Literacy Basics: Demystifying complex financial concepts like compound interest, diversification, and retirement planning through engaging explainers, infographics, and short videos.
• Sustainable and Impact Investing (ESG): Highlighting investment opportunities that align with social and environmental values, showcasing the positive impact of their investment choices.
• Achieving Financial Independence and Early Retirement (FIRE): Exploring strategies for achieving financial freedom and pursuing passions, emphasizing the importance of saving and investing early.
• Debt Management & Student Loan Strategies: Addressing the unique financial burdens faced by younger generations and providing practical advice for managing debt and student loans.

2. Building a Private Online Community: Instead of relying on public platforms, Dr. Santos chose to build a private Facebook group as the central hub of the community. This provided a sense of exclusivity and encouraged open and honest discussions. An Instagram account was created to amplify content and drive traffic to the private group.

3. Consistent and Engaging Content Strategy: A detailed content calendar was developed, outlining daily posts across both platforms. The content mix included:

• Educational articles and blog posts: Providing in-depth insights on various financial topics.
• Interactive polls and quizzes: Gauging audience understanding and sparking conversations.
• Live Q&A sessions with Dr. Santos: Addressing audience questions and building trust.
• Success stories and client testimonials: Showcasing the real-world benefits of financial planning.
• Behind-the-scenes glimpses into the firm: Humanizing the brand and fostering a sense of connection.

The decision-making framework emphasized a "value-first" approach. The community's primary goal was to provide valuable financial education and support, rather than directly pitching investment products. This was crucial in building trust and establishing Santos Financial as a reliable resource for financial guidance.

Technical Implementation

The community was built and managed using readily available and cost-effective tools:

• Facebook Group (Private): The core platform for community interaction. Facebook's built-in moderation tools were used to maintain a safe and respectful environment. Membership was granted after answering a few basic questions to ensure alignment with the community's purpose.
• Instagram: Used for content amplification and driving traffic to the Facebook group. Instagram Stories were utilized for quick tips, polls, and behind-the-scenes content.
• Buffer: Used to schedule content across both Facebook and Instagram, ensuring consistent posting and optimizing reach. Buffer's analytics provided insights into post performance and audience engagement. The paid plan was used, costing $100/month.
• Native Platform Analytics: Facebook Group Insights and Instagram Insights were used to track key metrics such as:
  • Engagement Rate: The percentage of members interacting with content (likes, comments, shares).
  • Reach: The number of unique users who saw the content.
  • Referral Traffic: The number of users clicking through from Instagram to the Facebook group.
  • Group Growth: The rate at which new members were joining the community.
• Lead Tracking: Each new client was asked how they found Santos Financial, allowing for accurate attribution of referrals originating from the online community. This involved adding a "Referred by Community" option to the firm's onboarding questionnaire.

The technical implementation also involved establishing a documented content creation workflow. Each week, Dr. Santos dedicated 4 hours to researching, writing, and scheduling content. A junior staff member spent an additional 4 hours per week managing the community, responding to comments, and moderating discussions. The financial investment in these tools and the allocation of staff time represented a significant, but manageable, cost.

Results & ROI

The community-driven approach yielded significant positive results within a six-month period:

• Next-Generation Client Referrals Increased by 35%: Referrals from clients under 40 increased from an average of 8 per quarter to 11 per quarter. This directly translated into an estimated $1.65 million increase in assets under management based on the average initial investment size of $150,000 per new client.
• Website Traffic from Social Media Increased by 60%: Social media became a significant source of website traffic, driving more potential clients to explore the firm's services.
• Engagement Rate Significantly Improved: The average engagement rate on Facebook posts increased from 2% to 12%, indicating a much higher level of interaction and interest. On Instagram, the average engagement rate increased from 1% to 7%.
• Cost Per Acquisition Decreased by 75%: By attracting clients through organic community engagement, the cost per acquisition dropped from $10,000 (for the direct mail campaign) to approximately $2,500, significantly improving marketing efficiency. This calculation included the cost of the Buffer subscription, the staff time allocated to community management, and the time spent on content creation.
• Younger Client Retention Increased by 8%: The retention rate for younger clients increased from 78% to 86%, demonstrably lowering churn and increasing the lifetime value of these clients.
• Brand Awareness Improved: Increased visibility in social media spaces boosted the firm's online presence and enhanced its reputation as a forward-thinking and client-focused financial advisor.

The ROI of the community initiative was calculated as follows: The estimated increase in revenue from the increased AUM as a result of the campaign ($1,650,000 x average advisory fee of 1% = $16,500), divided by the total cost of the initiative over six months (Buffer subscription of $600 + staff time of 8 hours per week x $50/hour x 26 weeks = $10,400. Total cost = $11,000). The ROI was $16,500 / $11,000 = 1.5, or 150%.

Key Takeaways

1. Understand Your Target Audience's Values: Tailor your content and messaging to resonate with the specific interests and priorities of the next-generation investor. Focus on financial literacy, ethical investing, and achieving life goals beyond financial gain.
2. Build a Community, Not Just a Marketing Campaign: Create a space for meaningful interaction and build trust through valuable content and genuine engagement.
3. Consistency is Key: Develop a consistent content schedule and maintain a regular presence on the chosen platforms.
4. Track Your Results and Iterate: Monitor key metrics such as engagement rate, website traffic, and lead generation to measure the effectiveness of your efforts and make data-driven adjustments.
5. Embrace a Value-First Approach: Focus on providing valuable financial education and support, rather than directly pitching investment products. This will build trust and establish your firm as a reliable resource for financial guidance.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors personalize client communications at scale. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.