Tax Efficient Portfolio Restructuring for Business Owners: 28% Tax Savings
Executive Summary
Many business owners find themselves holding highly appreciated assets within their investment portfolios, creating significant tax liabilities when diversification becomes necessary. Legacy Bridge Advisors partnered with a successful entrepreneur facing this very challenge. By implementing a multi-faceted tax-efficient restructuring strategy encompassing tax-loss harvesting, qualified opportunity zones, and charitable giving, we achieved a 28% reduction in projected capital gains taxes while simultaneously optimizing their portfolio for long-term growth.
The Challenge
John Miller, the founder and CEO of a thriving software company, had accumulated a substantial investment portfolio over the past two decades. A significant portion of this portfolio consisted of company stock purchased during the company’s early stages, now worth $3.5 million—representing a massive unrealized capital gain of $2.8 million.
While John recognized the importance of diversifying his holdings to mitigate risk and pursue new investment opportunities, he was understandably concerned about the potential tax implications. Selling the highly appreciated stock would trigger a substantial capital gains tax liability, estimated at $672,000 (24% federal capital gains tax rate) plus applicable state taxes, significantly impacting his overall wealth.
Furthermore, John was also passionate about supporting local community initiatives and regularly contributed to charitable organizations. He wanted to find a way to incorporate his philanthropic goals into his financial planning strategy in a tax-advantaged manner. He was also looking to invest some of his gains into commercial real estate, potentially adding to his tax burdens. Finding a solution that addressed all these complex, interwoven concerns was critical. He stated, “I want to diversify and give back without giving a huge chunk to the government.”
The Approach
Legacy Bridge Advisors adopted a holistic and customized approach to address John's challenges, focusing on minimizing tax liabilities while aligning his portfolio with his long-term financial goals and philanthropic objectives. Our strategy involved three key components:
1. Strategic Tax-Loss Harvesting: We initiated a comprehensive review of John’s existing portfolio to identify opportunities for tax-loss harvesting. This involved selling assets that had experienced losses to offset capital gains realized from the sale of a portion of his company stock. We carefully selected underperforming investments, totaling approximately $200,000 in losses, to offset a portion of the $2.8 million capital gain. This reduced the taxable gain by $200,000, lowering the immediate tax impact.
2. Investment in a Qualified Opportunity Zone (QOZ): Recognizing John's interest in real estate and his desire to defer capital gains taxes, we explored investment options in Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZs). We identified a promising real estate development project in a designated QOZ, which aligned with John's investment preferences. By investing $500,000 of the proceeds from the sale of his company stock into the QOZ project, John was able to defer capital gains taxes on that amount until 2027. Furthermore, if the QOZ investment is held for at least ten years, the capital gains generated from the QOZ investment itself may be entirely tax-free. This strategy not only provided a tax deferral but also offered the potential for long-term tax-free growth.
3. Charitable Contribution Strategy: To further reduce John's tax liability and support his philanthropic goals, we recommended contributing a portion of his appreciated stock directly to a qualified charitable organization. By donating $100,000 worth of his company stock, John was able to deduct the fair market value of the stock from his income, reducing his overall taxable income. Importantly, he avoided paying capital gains taxes on the appreciated value of the donated stock. We coordinated this donation strategy with John’s CPA to ensure maximum tax benefits and compliance with IRS regulations.
We rigorously considered alternative approaches, including installment sales and charitable remainder trusts. However, these options proved less suitable given John's specific circumstances and investment objectives. The chosen strategy offered the optimal combination of tax benefits, portfolio diversification, and alignment with his philanthropic goals.
Technical Implementation
The successful implementation of this tax-efficient restructuring strategy relied on a combination of specialized tools, meticulous planning, and close collaboration.
- Tax Software Integration: We utilized advanced tax planning software, specifically Holistiplan and RightCapital, to model various scenarios and quantify the potential tax benefits of each strategy. These tools allowed us to accurately estimate the impact of tax-loss harvesting, QOZ investments, and charitable contributions on John's overall tax liability. The software also facilitated the generation of detailed reports for documentation and compliance purposes.
- Coordination with CPA: We worked closely with John’s Certified Public Accountant (CPA) throughout the entire process. We shared detailed tax projections and strategies for review and approval. This collaboration ensured that all actions were in compliance with relevant tax laws and regulations and that John's individual tax situation was properly considered.
- QOZ Due Diligence: Our team conducted thorough due diligence on the selected QOZ investment project. This involved analyzing the project's financials, assessing the developer's track record, and evaluating the potential risks and returns associated with the investment. We also consulted with legal counsel specializing in QOZ investments to ensure compliance with all applicable regulations.
- Asset Allocation Modeling: Post-restructuring, we rebalanced John’s portfolio based on his risk tolerance and long-term investment objectives, using Morningstar Advisor Workstation to optimize asset allocation. The new portfolio included a diversified mix of stocks, bonds, and alternative investments, aiming to enhance long-term growth potential while managing risk effectively. We accounted for the illiquidity of the QOZ investment in the overall portfolio construction.
The calculations behind the 28% tax savings were complex. Without our strategy, the initial estimate of $672,000 in federal capital gains taxes would have been due. With our strategy, John paid taxes on only $2.8 million - $200,000 (tax loss harvesting) - $100,000 (charitable contribution) - $500,000 (QOZ Investment) = $2,000,000. At a 24% rate, the tax due on that $2,000,000 is $480,000. $672,000 - $480,000 = $192,000 in tax savings. $192,000 / $672,000 = 28.57% savings.
Results & ROI
The implemented tax-efficient restructuring strategy yielded significant results for John Miller:
- 28% Reduction in Capital Gains Taxes: As detailed above, the combined effect of tax-loss harvesting, the QOZ investment, and the charitable contribution resulted in a 28% reduction in John's federal capital gains tax liability. This translated to a significant cash savings of $192,000.
- Tax Deferral of $500,000 in Capital Gains: The QOZ investment allowed John to defer capital gains taxes on $500,000 of the proceeds from the sale of his company stock until 2027, providing him with additional time to plan for his future tax obligations.
- Enhanced Portfolio Diversification: The restructuring strategy enabled John to diversify his portfolio, reducing his concentration in company stock and spreading his investments across a wider range of asset classes. This improved the portfolio's risk-adjusted return potential.
- Philanthropic Impact: John was able to support his favorite charitable organization through a tax-advantaged donation, further aligning his financial planning with his personal values. The $100,000 charitable contribution allowed him to make a meaningful impact on his community while reducing his taxable income.
- Projected Long-Term Portfolio Growth: Based on our projections, the restructured portfolio is expected to outperform the original concentrated portfolio over the long term, due to its improved diversification and tax efficiency. We project an average annual return increase of 0.75% due to the tax advantages and diversification benefits.
Key Takeaways
- Holistic Tax Planning is Crucial: Business owners with highly appreciated assets should adopt a comprehensive tax planning approach that integrates investment strategies with charitable giving and other tax-advantaged opportunities.
- Leverage Tax-Loss Harvesting Proactively: Regularly review portfolios to identify opportunities for tax-loss harvesting. Even small losses can be used to offset capital gains and reduce overall tax liability.
- Explore Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZs): QOZs can provide significant tax benefits for investors seeking to defer or eliminate capital gains taxes, especially for those interested in real estate investments. But be sure to conduct thorough due diligence.
- Charitable Giving Can Be Mutually Beneficial: Consider donating appreciated assets directly to qualified charitable organizations to reduce taxable income and avoid capital gains taxes while supporting worthy causes.
- Collaborate with Tax Professionals: Partner with a qualified CPA to ensure compliance with all applicable tax laws and regulations and to optimize tax benefits based on individual circumstances.
About Golden Door Asset
Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors make data-driven investment decisions and deliver personalized financial advice at scale. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.