Secured $420K in Tax Savings Through Proactive Cash Flow Analysis

Secured $420K in Tax Savings Through Proactive Cash Flow Analysis

Executive Summary

Many new clients onboarded by RIAs leave significant tax optimization opportunities on the table. Luminary Wealth Partners faced this challenge and proactively implemented a comprehensive cash flow analysis into their onboarding process. By leveraging this approach, they identified and secured $420,000 in tax savings over five years for a single client, significantly enhancing the client's financial outlook and fostering a stronger advisor-client relationship.

The Challenge

Luminary Wealth Partners prides itself on delivering exceptional financial planning and investment management services. However, they recognized a recurring theme with new clients: a lack of proactive tax planning during the initial onboarding phase. Many clients, while diligent savers, weren't strategically managing their cash flow to maximize tax efficiency. This often resulted in missed opportunities for tax-advantaged investing and unnecessary tax liabilities.

Consider the case of Mr. and Mrs. Davies, a couple approaching retirement with $2.5 million in assets. They had been with a previous advisor for years but felt their tax situation wasn't being adequately addressed. Their income consisted primarily of Mrs. Davies' $150,000 salary and Mr. Davies' $40,000 in Social Security benefits. Their previous advisor focused heavily on asset allocation but paid less attention to the intricacies of their cash flow.

Upon initial review, Luminary identified several areas where the Davieses were potentially overpaying taxes. They were:

• Failing to maximize contributions to tax-deferred retirement accounts: While they were contributing to their 401(k)s, they weren't maximizing the allowable contributions, leaving roughly $12,000 per year in potential tax savings on the table (assuming a combined marginal tax rate of 25%).
• Investing in taxable accounts without considering tax implications: A significant portion of their investments was held in taxable brokerage accounts, generating taxable dividends and capital gains. The Davieses were incurring an estimated $15,000 annually in unnecessary capital gains taxes due to a buy-and-hold strategy that didn't account for tax efficiency.
• Not strategically timing charitable giving: The Davieses made consistent charitable donations throughout the year, but they weren't bundling their donations or using appreciated securities, missing an opportunity to further reduce their taxable income. They donated approximately $5,000 annually, a sum that could be significantly more impactful if strategically managed for tax advantages.
• Overlooking Roth conversion opportunities: With their income level likely to decrease in retirement, there was a window of opportunity to strategically convert traditional IRA assets to Roth IRAs, potentially locking in lower tax rates and avoiding future required minimum distributions (RMDs).
• No formal Roth planning: The client had no assets in a Roth account, and therefore, had no income tax diversification, increasing their tax burdens now and in retirement.

These oversights, common among new clients, highlighted the need for a more proactive and comprehensive approach to cash flow analysis during onboarding. Luminary understood that optimizing a client's financial picture required more than just asset allocation; it demanded a deep understanding of their cash flow and its tax implications.

The Approach

Luminary Wealth Partners revamped their onboarding process to incorporate a comprehensive cash flow analysis as a central component. This involved several key steps:

1. Initial Data Gathering & Discovery: The onboarding process now begins with a detailed questionnaire and interview focused on understanding the client's current cash flow, income sources, expenses, and existing tax strategies (or lack thereof). This includes requesting tax returns, brokerage statements, and other relevant financial documents. The goal is to create a complete picture of the client's financial life from the outset.
2. Cash Flow Modeling & Scenario Analysis: Once the data is collected, Luminary utilizes financial planning software (specifically eMoney Advisor, detailed below) to create a comprehensive cash flow model. This model projects the client's income, expenses, and taxes over a multi-year period, allowing advisors to identify potential tax inefficiencies and opportunities for optimization. Multiple scenarios are run, including different investment strategies, retirement dates, and tax law changes, to understand the potential impact of each decision.
3. Tax-Advantaged Investment Strategy Development: Based on the cash flow analysis, Luminary develops a personalized tax-advantaged investment strategy. This may involve reallocating assets to more tax-efficient vehicles, maximizing contributions to tax-deferred retirement accounts, implementing a Roth conversion strategy, and strategically timing charitable giving.
4. Client Education & Communication: Luminary places a strong emphasis on educating clients about the tax implications of their financial decisions. They communicate the rationale behind each recommendation in clear and concise terms, ensuring that clients understand the potential benefits and risks. Regular communication and updates are provided to keep clients informed and engaged.
5. Ongoing Monitoring & Adjustment: The cash flow analysis and tax-advantaged investment strategy are not static. Luminary continuously monitors the client's financial situation and makes adjustments as needed to reflect changes in income, expenses, tax laws, and investment performance. This ensures that the client remains on track to achieve their financial goals while minimizing their tax liability.
6. Tax Location Optimization: Luminary works with the client to determine which assets should reside in taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-free accounts to minimize taxes owed.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation of Luminary's proactive cash flow analysis relies on two key software platforms: eMoney Advisor and Holistiplan.

• eMoney Advisor: This comprehensive financial planning software serves as the foundation for Luminary's cash flow modeling and scenario analysis. eMoney allows advisors to:

  • Import and aggregate financial data from various sources, including brokerage accounts, bank accounts, and credit cards.
  • Create detailed cash flow projections based on the client's income, expenses, and assets.
  • Model different investment scenarios and their potential tax implications.
  • Generate reports that illustrate the impact of various tax strategies, such as Roth conversions and charitable giving.
  • Integrate with other financial planning tools, such as Holistiplan.

• Holistiplan: This tax planning software integrates directly with eMoney Advisor and allows Luminary to:

  • Analyze the client's tax return (Form 1040) to identify potential tax optimization opportunities.
  • Project the client's future tax liability under different scenarios.
  • Generate recommendations for tax-efficient investment strategies, such as asset location optimization and tax-loss harvesting.
  • Produce client-friendly reports that summarize the tax implications of different financial decisions.

The process begins with importing the client's financial data into eMoney Advisor. This data is then used to create a baseline cash flow projection, which is further refined using information from the client's tax return analyzed in Holistiplan. The advisors then use eMoney's scenario planning capabilities to model the impact of various tax strategies, such as maximizing 401(k) contributions, implementing a Roth conversion strategy, and strategically timing charitable giving. These scenarios are then compared to the baseline projection to quantify the potential tax savings.

For example, in the case of the Davieses, the advisors used eMoney to model the impact of increasing their 401(k) contributions to the maximum allowable amount. The software projected that this would reduce their taxable income by $12,000 per year, resulting in tax savings of approximately $3,000 annually (assuming a combined marginal tax rate of 25%).

Similarly, Holistiplan was used to analyze their past tax returns and identify opportunities for tax-loss harvesting. The software identified unrealized losses in their taxable brokerage account that could be used to offset capital gains, potentially reducing their tax liability by several thousand dollars.

The integration between eMoney Advisor and Holistiplan allows Luminary to streamline the tax planning process and provide clients with comprehensive, data-driven recommendations.

Results & ROI

By implementing a proactive cash flow analysis during onboarding, Luminary Wealth Partners achieved significant results for the Davieses:

• $420,000 in Tax Savings Over Five Years: Through a combination of strategies, including maximizing 401(k) contributions, Roth conversions, tax-loss harvesting, and strategic charitable giving, Luminary projected that the Davieses would save approximately $84,000 per year in taxes, totaling $420,000 over five years. This includes savings from both federal and state income taxes.
• Increased Retirement Income: By reducing their tax liability, the Davieses were able to retain more of their income, increasing their available funds for retirement spending. This resulted in a projected increase in their sustainable retirement income of approximately $3,000 per month.
• Improved Client Confidence: The proactive approach and tangible tax savings instilled a sense of confidence in the Davieses, strengthening their relationship with Luminary and increasing their likelihood of remaining a long-term client. The Davieses even referred two of their friends to Luminary, resulting in new business for the firm.
• Enhanced Firm Reputation: Luminary's commitment to proactive tax planning has helped to differentiate them from other RIAs and enhance their reputation as a trusted financial advisor. This has resulted in increased client referrals and new business opportunities.
• Improved Investment Performance: Tax optimized portfolios often perform better than non-tax optimized portfolios due to the reduced tax burden.

Specifically, Luminary implemented the following for the Davieses:

• Maximized 401(k) Contributions: This resulted in ~$3,000/year in tax savings, or $15,000 over five years.
• Implemented Roth Conversions: This strategy reduced future taxes owed by an estimated $50,000 over the five years, as the Davieses’ tax bracket was projected to increase in retirement.
• Strategic Charitable Giving: By bundling donations into a single year and donating appreciated securities, the Davieses reduced their tax liability by $5,000, or $25,000 over five years.
• Tax Loss Harvesting: By harvesting capital losses to offset gains, the client saved $1,000 a year, totaling $5,000 in tax savings.
• Tax Location Optimization: Properly allocating assets across different account types saved the client an estimated $9,000 per year, for $45,000 in tax savings across five years.
• Planning for future required minimum distributions was critical for limiting long-term taxation of retirement assets.

Key Takeaways

1. Proactive tax planning should be a central component of the client onboarding process. Don't wait until the end of the year to address tax issues. By incorporating cash flow analysis and tax planning into the onboarding process, you can identify opportunities for tax optimization from day one.
2. Leverage technology to streamline the tax planning process. Financial planning software and tax planning tools can help you to automate data gathering, model different scenarios, and generate client-friendly reports.
3. Educate clients about the tax implications of their financial decisions. Clients are more likely to follow your recommendations if they understand the rationale behind them. Take the time to explain the potential benefits and risks of different tax strategies.
4. Continuously monitor and adjust the client's tax strategy. Tax laws and financial circumstances can change over time. It's important to continuously monitor the client's situation and make adjustments as needed to ensure that they remain on track to achieve their financial goals while minimizing their tax liability.
5. Tax Planning is more valuable than asset allocation. Investors place an enormous amount of focus on investment asset allocation, which has a much smaller impact on performance than properly planning for income taxes.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors uncover hidden client needs and deliver hyper-personalized advice at scale. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.