Increasing Charitable Impact: Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT)

Increasing Charitable Impact: Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT)

Executive Summary

Mr. Andrew Ferguson, a successful entrepreneur, sought to maximize his charitable giving while simultaneously planning for his family's future financial security. Golden Door Asset recommended and implemented a Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT) to address this challenge. The CLAT allowed Mr. Ferguson to provide $50,000 annually to his preferred charity for a decade, with the remaining assets potentially reverting to his family at a significantly reduced estate tax cost, resulting in an estimated tax benefit exceeding $100,000.

The Challenge

Andrew Ferguson, the 62-year-old founder of a thriving tech company, was deeply committed to supporting local education initiatives. He had been making annual donations of $25,000 to a local school but wanted to increase his impact without negatively affecting his estate plan. With a net worth exceeding $8 million and anticipating further growth in his business, Mr. Ferguson was also concerned about potential estate taxes impacting his heirs. His current estate plan, while adequate, didn't proactively incorporate his charitable goals into a broader wealth transfer strategy.

Specifically, Mr. Ferguson faced the following challenges:

• Limited Annual Giving Impact: His current $25,000 annual donation, while generous, felt insufficient given his capacity. He aimed to double this contribution without jeopardizing his family's financial security.
• Estate Tax Exposure: Projections indicated that his estate could be subject to significant federal estate taxes upon his passing, potentially diminishing the inheritance for his children and grandchildren. He was seeking strategies to minimize this tax burden.
• Lack of Integrated Planning: His philanthropic efforts were distinct from his estate planning, resulting in missed opportunities for tax optimization and strategic asset allocation.
• Desire for Future Family Benefit: While primarily focused on charitable giving, Mr. Ferguson also hoped that the charitable strategy could ultimately benefit his family financially, offering a long-term legacy.

He expressed a desire for a strategy that aligned his charitable objectives with his overall wealth management and estate planning goals, providing both immediate benefits to his chosen charity and potential future benefits to his family.

The Approach

Golden Door Asset conducted a comprehensive review of Mr. Ferguson's financial situation, including his assets, liabilities, income, expenses, and estate planning documents. We then developed a customized CLAT strategy designed to achieve his charitable and estate planning objectives.

Our approach involved the following key steps:

1. Needs Assessment: We began by thoroughly understanding Mr. Ferguson's charitable priorities, his desired level of giving, and his long-term financial goals for his family.
2. CLAT Education: We educated Mr. Ferguson on the mechanics and benefits of a Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT), explaining how it could fulfill his charitable wishes while potentially reducing his estate tax liability.
3. Financial Modeling: Using our AI-powered planning tools, we created detailed financial projections illustrating the potential tax benefits and long-term impact of the CLAT under various market scenarios. These projections considered different asset growth rates, interest rates, and tax laws.
4. Trust Document Drafting: We collaborated with Mr. Ferguson's estate planning attorney to draft a legally sound CLAT agreement that accurately reflected his intentions and complied with all applicable tax regulations. The agreement specified the charity, the annuity payment amount, the term of the trust, and the beneficiaries who would receive the remaining assets at the end of the term.
5. Asset Allocation Strategy: We worked with Mr. Ferguson to determine the optimal assets to fund the CLAT, considering factors such as their potential for growth, income generation, and tax implications.
6. Implementation and Monitoring: We oversaw the transfer of assets to the CLAT and established a system for managing the annuity payments to the designated charity. We also provided ongoing monitoring of the trust's performance and made adjustments as needed to ensure it remained aligned with Mr. Ferguson's goals and objectives.

The CLAT strategy was chosen because it offered the optimal balance between charitable giving, estate tax reduction, and potential future benefit to Mr. Ferguson's family. We carefully considered alternative strategies, such as a Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT), but ultimately determined that the CLAT was the most suitable option given Mr. Ferguson's specific circumstances and objectives.

Technical Implementation

The CLAT was structured as follows:

• Initial Funding: Mr. Ferguson contributed $500,000 in marketable securities to the CLAT. These securities were chosen for their potential for long-term growth and dividend income.
• Annuity Payment: The CLAT was designed to pay $50,000 annually to the designated charity for a period of 10 years. This amount was determined based on Mr. Ferguson's desired level of giving and the applicable federal rate (AFR) at the time the CLAT was established.
• Applicable Federal Rate (AFR): The AFR, published monthly by the IRS, is a crucial factor in determining the tax implications of a CLAT. The lower the AFR at the time the CLAT is established, the greater the potential estate tax benefits. We strategically timed the establishment of the CLAT to take advantage of a relatively low AFR.
• Trust Term: The CLAT had a term of 10 years. At the end of the term, the remaining assets in the trust would revert to Mr. Ferguson's children, assuming he was still alive. If Mr. Ferguson passed away during the term, the assets would be distributed according to the terms of his estate plan.
• Tax Implications: The $50,000 annual payments to the charity were considered a charitable deduction on Mr. Ferguson's income tax return. However, because the assets were expected to revert to his family at the end of the term, the transfer to the CLAT was considered a taxable gift. The taxable gift amount was determined by discounting the present value of the annuity payments to the charity using the AFR. This resulted in a significantly lower taxable gift than the initial contribution of $500,000.
• Investment Management: The assets within the CLAT were managed by Golden Door Asset, using a diversified investment strategy designed to generate sufficient income to cover the annuity payments while also maximizing long-term growth potential. The strategy included a mix of stocks, bonds, and alternative investments.
• IRS Compliance: The CLAT was carefully structured to comply with all applicable IRS regulations, including those related to gift taxes, charitable deductions, and trust administration. We prepared all necessary tax filings and provided ongoing guidance to Mr. Ferguson and his estate planning attorney to ensure continued compliance.
• Golden Door Asset's AI Tools: Our internal AI-powered projection tools allowed us to model different scenarios with varying AFRs and asset growth assumptions. This gave Mr. Ferguson a clear understanding of potential outcomes and allowed us to optimize the trust structure for maximum benefit.

Results & ROI

The CLAT strategy delivered significant financial benefits for Mr. Ferguson and his family:

• Increased Charitable Giving: Mr. Ferguson was able to double his annual charitable giving from $25,000 to $50,000, making a more substantial impact on his chosen charity. Over the 10-year term of the CLAT, the charity received a total of $500,000.
• Potential Estate Tax Savings: By transferring assets to the CLAT, Mr. Ferguson effectively removed those assets from his taxable estate. The estimated estate tax savings resulting from the CLAT was over $100,000, based on current estate tax laws and projected asset growth.
• Future Family Benefit: At the end of the 10-year term, the remaining assets in the CLAT (estimated to be significantly higher than the initial $500,000 contribution, assuming reasonable investment growth) will revert to Mr. Ferguson's children, providing them with a substantial inheritance.
• Income Tax Deduction: Mr. Ferguson received an income tax deduction for the present value of the annuity payments to the charity, further reducing his overall tax burden. The present value of the charitable deduction was carefully calculated, maximizing its benefit.
• Improved Financial Planning: The CLAT strategy integrated Mr. Ferguson's charitable giving with his overall wealth management and estate planning, resulting in a more comprehensive and tax-efficient financial plan.
• Quantifiable ROI: For every $1 contributed to the CLAT, Mr. Ferguson projected returns of greater than $1.20 in overall tax and estate benefits, with future revenue potential upon reversion to his family.
• Annualized Return: The CLAT generated an average annualized return of 8% for the charity during the trust term and is projected to produce a similar return for Mr. Ferguson's children upon reversion.

Key Takeaways

1. Integrate Charitable Giving with Estate Planning: Don't treat charitable giving as a separate activity. Incorporate it into your overall estate plan to maximize tax benefits and achieve your philanthropic goals.
2. Consider CLATs for High-Net-Worth Individuals: A Charitable Lead Annuity Trust (CLAT) can be a powerful tool for high-net-worth individuals seeking to increase their charitable impact while simultaneously reducing their estate tax liability.
3. Time the Establishment of CLATs Strategically: The applicable federal rate (AFR) plays a crucial role in determining the tax benefits of a CLAT. Time the establishment of the CLAT to take advantage of a relatively low AFR.
4. Utilize AI-Powered Planning Tools: Leveraging AI-powered financial planning tools can help you model different scenarios, optimize trust structures, and provide clients with a clear understanding of potential outcomes.
5. Collaborate with Estate Planning Attorneys: Work closely with estate planning attorneys to ensure that CLAT agreements are legally sound and comply with all applicable tax regulations.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors uncover hidden opportunities in client portfolios and build more sophisticated financial plans. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.