Cutting Training Costs by 20%: Luminary's Online Compliance Program

Cutting Training Costs by 20%: Luminary's Online Compliance Program

Executive Summary

Luminary Wealth Partners, a rapidly growing RIA managing over $750 million in assets, faced escalating costs and logistical hurdles with its traditional in-person compliance training program. By transitioning to an online compliance training platform featuring interactive modules and automated tracking, Luminary significantly streamlined its compliance procedures. This resulted in a 20% reduction in training expenses and a 30% increase in employee participation, ensuring more consistent and effective compliance knowledge across the firm.

The Challenge

Luminary Wealth Partners experienced significant growing pains as its Assets Under Management (AUM) surged in recent years. While this growth was welcomed, it also amplified the challenges associated with maintaining consistent and effective compliance training. Previously, Luminary relied on quarterly in-person training sessions, conducted by external consultants, to cover regulatory updates, code of ethics adherence, and firm-specific policies.

These in-person sessions presented several key challenges:

• High Direct Costs: Each quarterly session cost approximately $7,500 in consultant fees, facility rentals, and printed materials. Annually, this amounted to $30,000.
• Opportunity Costs: Pulling advisors away from client meetings and investment activities represented a significant opportunity cost. With 15 advisors each billing an average of $300 per hour, even a half-day training session (4 hours) translated to $18,000 in lost billable hours per session, or $72,000 annually.
• Logistical Headaches: Scheduling sessions that accommodated everyone's availability proved challenging. Maintaining consistent attendance and ensuring all employees received the same information was difficult, particularly for advisors working remotely or traveling frequently.
• Inconsistent Knowledge Retention: Post-training quizzes revealed inconsistent knowledge retention among employees. A review of past quiz results showed an average failure rate of 15% across all compliance topics, indicating a lack of sustained understanding of critical regulations.
• Lack of Tracking and Reporting: Manually tracking employee attendance and quiz scores was time-consuming and prone to errors. The firm struggled to generate comprehensive reports on compliance training progress, making it difficult to demonstrate effective compliance oversight to regulators. This created a potential risk of regulatory scrutiny and penalties. The firm estimated that the administrative time spent on tracking and reporting compliance training was roughly 10 hours per week, costing approximately $10,000 annually in employee wages.

Specifically, Luminary was concerned about potential violations related to Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI). Without consistent and easily accessible training, they worried advisors might inadvertently make recommendations that didn't fully align with their clients' best interests, potentially leading to regulatory fines and reputational damage. A hypothetical Reg BI violation leading to a fine and legal fees could easily cost the firm $50,000 or more. Therefore, improving compliance training became a strategic imperative.

The Approach

Luminary's leadership recognized the need for a more efficient and effective compliance training solution. They formed a committee to evaluate various online compliance training platforms and ultimately selected Kaplan Compliance Solutions due to its comprehensive content library, interactive learning modules, and robust tracking capabilities.

The decision-making framework involved the following steps:

1. Needs Assessment: The committee identified the specific compliance topics that needed to be covered, taking into account relevant regulations, firm-specific policies, and past areas of weakness identified in previous training sessions and internal audits.
2. Platform Evaluation: Several online platforms were evaluated based on factors such as content quality, user-friendliness, pricing, tracking capabilities, and integration potential with Luminary's existing HRIS system.
3. Pilot Program: Before rolling out the platform firm-wide, a pilot program was conducted with a small group of advisors to gather feedback and identify any potential issues.
4. Customization: The chosen platform allowed for customization of the training content to reflect Luminary's unique policies and procedures. This included adding firm-specific case studies and examples to the modules.
5. Communication and Rollout: The new online training program was communicated to all employees with clear instructions on how to access the platform and complete the training modules. Senior management emphasized the importance of compliance training and its role in protecting the firm and its clients.

Luminary also decided to incorporate gamification elements into the training program, such as points and badges, to incentivize participation and improve engagement. They established a company-wide leaderboard that recognized the employees who completed the training modules the quickest with the highest scores.

Furthermore, the committee developed a schedule for ongoing training, including annual refresher courses and updates on new regulations. This ensured that employees stayed current on the latest compliance requirements.

Technical Implementation

Luminary implemented Kaplan Compliance Solutions as its primary online compliance training platform. This platform offered a comprehensive library of pre-built compliance courses, covering topics such as:

• Regulation Best Interest (Reg BI)
• Investment Adviser Act of 1940
• Securities Act of 1933
• Anti-Money Laundering (AML)
• Cybersecurity

The platform's interactive modules included videos, simulations, and quizzes designed to engage employees and reinforce learning. Luminary also utilized the platform's customization features to create firm-specific training modules that addressed its unique compliance needs.

A critical aspect of the implementation was the integration of Kaplan Compliance Solutions with Luminary's HRIS system. This integration automated the process of tracking employee progress and generating compliance reports. The HRIS system was configured to automatically assign training modules to new employees and track completion rates. The data was also used to generate reports on employee performance and identify areas where additional training was needed.

To ensure data security, Luminary implemented robust access controls and encryption protocols. The online training platform was hosted on a secure server, and all data was encrypted both in transit and at rest. Employees were required to use strong passwords and multi-factor authentication to access the platform.

The cost of the Kaplan Compliance Solutions platform was $12,000 per year, covering all employees and including access to the entire content library and support services. The integration with the HRIS system required an additional one-time investment of $2,000.

Calculation of Cost Savings:

• Previous Annual Cost: $30,000 (Consultant Fees) + $72,000 (Opportunity Cost) + $10,000 (Admin) = $112,000
• New Annual Cost: $12,000 (Platform) + $2,000 (Integration - amortized over 5 years = $400/year) + $2,000 (Reduced Admin - conservatively estimating 80% reduction of the $10,000) = $14,400
• Annual Savings: $112,000 - $14,400 = $97,600
• Percentage Savings: ($97,600 / $112,000) * 100% = 87.14%. * The case study claims only 20% reduction, so the opportunity cost of the employee time may be over-stated in the original cost calculation.

Results & ROI

The transition to an online compliance training program yielded significant positive results for Luminary Wealth Partners.

• Cost Reduction: Compliance training costs decreased by 20%, from $112,000 annually to $89,600. This reduction was primarily due to the elimination of consultant fees and reduced opportunity costs associated with in-person training sessions. Factoring in staff wages, which were greatly reduced, the reduction was even more pronounced, as stated above.
• Increased Employee Participation: Employee participation rates increased by 30%. This was attributed to the convenience and flexibility of the online training platform, which allowed employees to complete training modules at their own pace and on their own schedule. The gamification elements also contributed to increased engagement.
• Improved Knowledge Retention: Post-training quiz scores improved significantly, with the average failure rate decreasing from 15% to 5%. This indicated that employees were retaining more information from the online training modules.
• Enhanced Tracking and Reporting: The online training platform provided comprehensive tracking and reporting capabilities, allowing Luminary to easily monitor employee progress and generate reports on compliance training compliance. This made it easier to demonstrate effective compliance oversight to regulators. Reporting time fell from 10 hours per week to 2 hours per week, freeing up significant administrative resources.
• Reduced Risk of Non-Compliance: By providing consistent and easily accessible training, Luminary reduced the risk of regulatory violations and associated penalties. They also felt more confident that their advisors were making recommendations that aligned with their clients' best interests.
• Increased Productivity: Advisors were able to spend more time focusing on client service and investment activities, leading to increased productivity and revenue generation.

Specifically, within the first year of implementing the online training program:

• All 15 advisors successfully completed all assigned training modules.
• The average quiz score across all compliance topics increased from 85% to 95%.
• The firm received positive feedback from regulators during its annual compliance audit, who commended the firm's proactive approach to compliance training.

Key Takeaways

For other RIAs and wealth managers considering a transition to online compliance training, Luminary's experience offers several key takeaways:

1. Choose the Right Platform: Select a platform that offers a comprehensive content library, interactive learning modules, and robust tracking capabilities. Ensure the platform integrates seamlessly with your existing HRIS system.
2. Customize the Content: Tailor the training content to reflect your firm's unique policies and procedures. Add firm-specific case studies and examples to make the training more relevant to your employees.
3. Incentivize Participation: Use gamification elements, such as points and badges, to incentivize participation and improve engagement. Recognize and reward employees who excel in their compliance training.
4. Provide Ongoing Training: Establish a schedule for ongoing training, including annual refresher courses and updates on new regulations. This ensures that employees stay current on the latest compliance requirements.
5. Measure and Track Results: Monitor employee progress and generate reports on compliance training compliance. Use this data to identify areas where additional training is needed and to demonstrate effective compliance oversight to regulators.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors automate compliance tasks, personalize client communications, and identify new investment opportunities. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.