Charitable IRA Rollover: $120K Avoided Taxable Income
Executive Summary
A retired client of Harrington Legacy Advisors faced significant tax liabilities due to required minimum distributions (RMDs) from their IRA. To mitigate this, we implemented a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD) strategy, enabling direct donations from the IRA to qualifying charities. Over five years, this approach successfully avoided $120,000 in taxable income for the client, allowing them to support their philanthropic interests while optimizing their tax situation.
The Challenge
Mr. and Mrs. Thompson, both in their early 70s, approached Harrington Legacy Advisors with concerns about their increasing tax burden in retirement. Their combined taxable income, primarily from Social Security, a small pension, and withdrawals from their traditional IRA, was pushing them into a higher tax bracket. A significant portion of their taxable income was attributed to the Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) from their IRA.
Specifically, Mr. Thompson’s IRA had grown to $800,000. Based on his age and the IRS life expectancy tables, his annual RMD was approximately $32,000 (4% of $800,000). This $32,000 was added to their existing taxable income, resulting in an estimated federal tax liability of $8,000 annually, or a 25% tax rate on the RMD.
Beyond the immediate tax liability, the Thompsons were philanthropically inclined and regularly donated $24,000 annually to various charities. Prior to engaging Harrington Legacy Advisors, these charitable donations were made with after-tax dollars. This meant they were first paying income tax on the money and then claiming the charitable deduction on their tax return. Due to the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act's increased standard deduction, they weren't always able to deduct the full amount of their charitable giving, diminishing the overall tax benefit. They wanted a more efficient way to support their favorite causes while minimizing their tax exposure. The challenge was to restructure their giving strategy to maximize charitable impact while simultaneously reducing their taxable income.
The Approach
Our approach centered on leveraging Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) from Mr. Thompson’s IRA. QCDs allow individuals age 70 ½ or older to donate up to $100,000 per year directly from their IRA to a qualified charity. Critically, the QCD counts towards the IRA owner's RMD for the year, but it is excluded from their taxable income.
We began by thoroughly evaluating the Thompsons’ overall financial picture, including their income sources, expenses, tax situation, and charitable giving goals. We determined that utilizing QCDs was a suitable strategy to address their concerns. We then outlined a plan where Mr. Thompson would satisfy a portion of his RMD requirement each year through QCDs, effectively replacing their after-tax charitable donations with pre-tax donations from the IRA.
Our strategy involved:
- Identifying Qualified Charities: We worked with the Thompsons to ensure that all recipient charities were 501(c)(3) organizations, meeting the IRS requirements for QCD eligibility. We also verified that none of the charities provided any goods or services in exchange for the donations, as this could jeopardize the QCD status.
- Coordination with IRA Custodian: We collaborated closely with Mr. Thompson’s IRA custodian to ensure the proper execution of the QCDs. This involved completing the necessary paperwork and providing instructions on how to directly transfer the funds from the IRA to the designated charities.
- Tax Planning and Coordination: We worked in tandem with the Thompsons’ tax advisor to ensure that the QCDs were properly reported on their tax return and that the corresponding reduction in taxable income was accurately reflected.
- Ongoing Monitoring and Adjustment: We monitored the Thompsons’ financial situation and tax laws to ensure that the QCD strategy remained optimal. We also adjusted the QCD amounts each year as needed, based on changes in their RMD requirements and charitable giving goals.
- Communication and Education: We proactively communicated with the Thompsons throughout the process, explaining the benefits and implications of the QCD strategy and answering any questions they had. We also provided educational materials to help them better understand the rules and regulations surrounding QCDs.
Technical Implementation
The technical implementation of the QCD strategy required careful coordination between Harrington Legacy Advisors, the Thompsons' IRA custodian (Charles Schwab), and their tax advisor (a local CPA firm).
Here's a breakdown of the key technical aspects:
- IRA Custodial Coordination: We facilitated the direct transfer of funds from Mr. Thompson's traditional IRA to the qualified charities through Charles Schwab. This involved submitting QCD request forms to Schwab, specifying the charity name, address, and donation amount. Schwab then initiated the wire transfers or mailed the checks directly to the charities, ensuring the funds never passed through Mr. Thompson’s hands. This is crucial for the donation to qualify as a QCD. The wire transfer fees (approximately $25 per transaction) were factored into the overall cost-benefit analysis, demonstrating that the tax savings far outweighed these minor expenses.
- RMD Calculation and Optimization: We used specialized financial planning software (eMoney Advisor) to project Mr. Thompson's RMD for each year of the five-year period, factoring in the IRA's growth rate and actuarial life expectancy tables. We then determined the optimal QCD amount each year to balance tax savings with the Thompsons' charitable giving goals. For example, in year one, his RMD was $32,000, and he elected to use $24,000 as a QCD, meeting 75% of his RMD obligation through charitable giving. The remaining $8,000 was withdrawn and taxed as ordinary income.
- Tax Reporting and Documentation: To ensure proper tax reporting, we provided the Thompsons and their tax advisor with detailed documentation of each QCD, including the charity's name, address, donation date, and amount. We also provided instructions on how to report the QCD on Form 1040. The Thompsons received a Form 1099-R from Schwab, reflecting the gross distribution from the IRA. We advised them to report the distribution as a QCD on Schedule 1 (Form 1040), line 5. Their tax advisor confirmed that the QCD was properly excluded from their taxable income.
- 5-Year Projection Modeling: We created a detailed financial model projecting the impact of the QCD strategy over a five-year period. This model included assumptions for IRA growth rates (6% annually), tax bracket rates, and charitable giving amounts. The model clearly demonstrated the tax savings that would be achieved by utilizing QCDs compared to making after-tax charitable donations. We used Monte Carlo simulation within the financial planning software to stress-test the projections under different market conditions.
Results & ROI
The implementation of the QCD strategy yielded significant financial benefits for the Thompsons over a five-year period:
- Taxable Income Avoided: By utilizing QCDs to satisfy a portion of their RMDs, the Thompsons avoided a total of $120,000 in taxable income over five years ($24,000 per year x 5 years).
- Federal Tax Savings: Assuming a 25% federal tax rate, the Thompsons saved approximately $30,000 in federal taxes over five years ($6,000 per year x 5 years). This translates to an annual tax savings of $6,000.
- Increased Charitable Impact: The Thompsons were able to donate the same amount to their chosen charities but with a significant tax advantage. Their charitable contributions were effectively "pre-tax," increasing the efficiency of their giving.
- Simplified Tax Reporting: The QCD strategy simplified the Thompsons' tax reporting process by eliminating the need to itemize deductions for charitable contributions.
- Peace of Mind: The Thompsons gained peace of mind knowing that they were optimizing their financial situation and making a meaningful impact on the causes they care about.
Before implementing the QCD strategy, the Thompsons were paying approximately $8,000 in federal taxes annually on their RMDs and then donating after-tax dollars. After implementing the QCD strategy, they reduced their federal tax liability by $6,000 annually, effectively donating with pre-tax dollars and simplifying their tax filing process. The overall ROI was substantial, demonstrating the significant financial benefits of strategic charitable planning. The percentage return can be estimated as $30,000 savings / $120,000 rollover = 25% return.
Key Takeaways
Here are some actionable insights for other advisors:
- Understand the QCD Rules: Ensure a thorough understanding of the QCD rules and regulations, including eligibility requirements, contribution limits, and reporting requirements.
- Coordinate with IRA Custodians and Tax Advisors: Establish strong relationships with IRA custodians and tax advisors to facilitate the seamless execution of QCDs and ensure accurate tax reporting.
- Develop a Holistic Financial Plan: Integrate QCDs into a comprehensive financial plan that considers the client's overall financial situation, tax situation, and charitable giving goals.
- Communicate Proactively with Clients: Explain the benefits and implications of QCDs clearly and concisely to clients, and keep them informed throughout the process.
- Monitor and Adjust as Needed: Regularly monitor the client's financial situation and tax laws to ensure that the QCD strategy remains optimal. Adjust the QCD amounts as needed based on changes in RMD requirements and charitable giving goals.
About Golden Door Asset
Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors identify and implement tax-efficient strategies like QCDs, optimize client portfolios, and deliver personalized financial advice at scale. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.