Boosting Client Trust: 99% Transparency with Fees

Boosting Client Trust: 99% Transparency with Fees

Executive Summary

Santos Financial, a growing Registered Investment Advisor (RIA) firm, faced mounting client confusion regarding their fee structure, potentially jeopardizing client retention. By implementing a comprehensive and transparent fee disclosure policy, Santos Financial empowered clients with clear and accessible information. This initiative led to a remarkable 5% increase in client retention and achieved a 99% client satisfaction rate regarding fee transparency, solidifying trust and fostering long-term client relationships.

The Challenge

In today's complex financial landscape, maintaining client trust is paramount for RIAs. Santos Financial, while providing excellent investment advice and portfolio management, experienced increasing client inquiries and concerns surrounding its fee structure. The previous fee disclosure process, while compliant with regulations, lacked the clarity and consistency clients needed for complete understanding.

Specifically, clients expressed confusion about the following:

• Tiered Asset Management Fees: Santos Financial used a tiered fee structure based on assets under management (AUM). For example, clients with $500,000 to $1 million in AUM paid 1.0% annually, while those with $1 million to $2 million paid 0.8%. Many clients struggled to understand how these tiers applied to their specific portfolio value and how the fee was calculated. One client, Mrs. Johnson, initially believed her $650,000 portfolio would be charged 0.8% because it was "closer" to the higher tier, leading to a frustrating phone call.

• Transaction Fees: While most trades were commission-free through their broker-dealer, some specialized investment vehicles, like certain REITs or limited partnerships, incurred transaction fees. These fees, averaging $15-$30 per trade, were often buried in quarterly statements, catching clients off guard. A client, Mr. Davis, noticed a $27 transaction fee on his quarterly statement and immediately called his advisor, concerned about "hidden charges." This issue consumed valuable advisor time explaining the specific circumstance.

• Performance Fees (Select Accounts): A small percentage of clients (approximately 5%) were enrolled in accounts with a performance-based fee structure, where Santos Financial received a percentage of the profits generated above a specified benchmark. The calculation of these fees, while compliant, was difficult for clients to grasp. One client, Dr. Lee, whose portfolio significantly outperformed the benchmark, questioned the accuracy of the performance fee calculation, stating, "It feels like I'm being penalized for my portfolio doing well."

• Inconsistent Disclosure: Different advisors within the firm sometimes used slightly different language when explaining fees, leading to inconsistencies and further client confusion. A survey revealed that only 65% of clients strongly agreed that the fees were explained clearly and consistently across all interactions with the firm. This inconsistency created doubt and eroded trust, as clients compared experiences and perceived unfairness.

These challenges highlighted the urgent need for a more transparent and client-friendly fee disclosure policy to mitigate confusion, enhance trust, and protect client relationships. The potential consequences of failing to address this issue included increased client attrition, negative word-of-mouth referrals, and potentially even regulatory scrutiny. Santos Financial recognized the imperative to transform its fee disclosure process into a competitive advantage.

The Approach

Santos Financial adopted a multi-faceted approach to address the challenges surrounding fee transparency. The core principle was to provide clients with clear, concise, and easily accessible information about all fees and charges associated with their accounts. The strategic framework consisted of:

1. Standardized Fee Disclosure Language: Developed a firm-wide standardized fee disclosure document, outlining all potential fees and charges in plain language, avoiding jargon and technical terms. This document became a mandatory part of the onboarding process for all new clients. Each fee type was defined clearly with examples.

2. Custom-Built Fee Disclosure Module: Invested in developing a custom fee disclosure module within the firm's existing client portal. This module allowed clients to view a detailed breakdown of the fees applicable to their specific accounts, updated in real-time.

3. Proactive Communication: Implemented a proactive communication strategy, including:

   • Annual Fee Reviews: Conducted annual fee reviews with each client to discuss their current fee structure and address any questions or concerns.
   • Fee Alerts: Implemented automated email alerts to notify clients of any transaction fees incurred on their accounts, along with a clear explanation of the charge.
   • Educational Materials: Created educational videos and infographics explaining the firm's fee structure in a simple and engaging format. These resources were made available on the firm's website and within the client portal.

4. Advisor Training: Provided comprehensive training to all advisors on the new fee disclosure policy and best practices for communicating fee information to clients. This training emphasized empathy, active listening, and the importance of addressing client concerns promptly and effectively.

5. Client Feedback Mechanism: Established a formal client feedback mechanism to continuously monitor client satisfaction with the fee disclosure process. This included regular client surveys and focus groups to identify areas for improvement.

The decision to invest in a custom-built fee disclosure module, rather than relying on generic solutions, stemmed from the firm's commitment to providing a truly personalized and seamless client experience. This module allowed Santos Financial to tailor the information to each client's specific circumstances and present it in a visually appealing and intuitive format.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation of Santos Financial's transparent fee disclosure initiative centered around the custom-built fee disclosure module within their client portal. The module was designed with a user-centric approach, prioritizing clarity and ease of navigation.

Key technical aspects include:

• Integration with Billing System: The fee disclosure module was seamlessly integrated with the firm's billing system, ensuring that fee calculations were accurate and up-to-date. The billing system used a waterfall calculation method for tiered AUM fees, meaning each tier was calculated independently to avoid sudden increases in fee percentages as AUM crossed tier thresholds. This prevented scenarios where a small increase in AUM resulted in a disproportionately large increase in fees.

• Automated Fee Calculation: The module automatically calculated the fees applicable to each client's account based on their AUM, investment holdings, and any applicable performance-based fees. The calculations followed SEC guidelines (specifically, referencing sections 205(a)(1) and (2) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 regarding advisory contracts) regarding proper disclosure of fee structures. For performance fees, the module displayed the benchmark used, the portfolio's performance relative to the benchmark, and the resulting performance fee amount. This information was presented in a clear and concise manner, using graphs and charts to illustrate the performance differential.

• Real-Time Updates: The fee information displayed in the module was updated in real-time, reflecting any changes in AUM, investment holdings, or fee schedules. This ensured that clients always had access to the most current and accurate fee information.

• Secure Data Storage: All fee-related data was stored securely using industry-standard encryption protocols to protect client privacy and confidentiality. The system complied with all relevant data privacy regulations, including GDPR and CCPA.

• API Integration with Broker-Dealer: The system leveraged API integration with the firm's broker-dealer to retrieve transaction fee information automatically. This eliminated the need for manual data entry and reduced the risk of errors. When transaction fees were incurred (e.g. $27 for certain fixed income purchases as previously discussed), the client portal immediately showed the transaction, a link to the trade confirmation, and a clearly written explanation regarding the fee.

• Audit Trail: The system maintained a comprehensive audit trail of all fee-related transactions and disclosures. This allowed Santos Financial to track client interactions and demonstrate compliance with regulatory requirements.

The system was built using a modern web framework (React) for the front-end and a robust Python-based API for the back-end. The database used was PostgreSQL. Regular security audits and penetration testing were conducted to ensure the system's security and integrity.

Results & ROI

The implementation of Santos Financial's transparent fee disclosure policy yielded significant positive results:

• Increased Client Retention: Client retention increased by 5% within the first year of implementation. This translates to retaining approximately $25 million in AUM (assuming an average client AUM of $500,000), preventing a significant loss of revenue.

• Improved Client Satisfaction: Client satisfaction with fee transparency increased dramatically, achieving a 99% satisfaction rate in post-implementation surveys. This was a significant improvement from the pre-implementation satisfaction rate of 65%. The Net Promoter Score (NPS) related to clarity of fees rose from 40 to 75.

• Reduced Client Inquiries: The number of client inquiries related to fees decreased by 70%. This freed up advisor time, allowing them to focus on providing more value-added services to clients. Each advisor saved approximately 5 hours per week, which was then allocated towards proactive financial planning and client outreach.

• Enhanced Brand Reputation: Santos Financial's commitment to transparency was recognized by industry publications and client testimonials, enhancing the firm's brand reputation and attracting new clients. They received the "Most Transparent RIA" award from a local financial publication.

• Reduced Compliance Risk: The clear and consistent fee disclosure process reduced the firm's compliance risk, minimizing the potential for regulatory scrutiny and fines.

• Financial Impact: Considering the increased client retention, reduced client inquiries, and enhanced brand reputation, Santos Financial estimates that the transparent fee disclosure initiative generated an additional $250,000 in revenue within the first year. This represents a significant return on investment (ROI) for the firm.

Before the initiative, average client tenure was 7.2 years. Post-implementation, average client tenure has risen to 7.9 years, projecting increased long-term value per client.

Key Takeaways

1. Transparency Builds Trust: Clear and consistent fee disclosures are essential for building and maintaining client trust. Don't hide fees; proactively explain them.
2. Invest in Technology: Technology can play a crucial role in streamlining the fee disclosure process and providing clients with easy access to fee information. A custom-built solution, while requiring upfront investment, can deliver superior results compared to generic solutions.
3. Proactive Communication is Key: Don't wait for clients to ask about fees. Proactively communicate fee information through various channels, including annual reviews, automated alerts, and educational materials.
4. Empower Your Advisors: Provide advisors with the training and resources they need to effectively communicate fee information to clients. Emphasize empathy and active listening skills.
5. Seek Client Feedback: Continuously monitor client satisfaction with the fee disclosure process and use feedback to identify areas for improvement. Regularly surveying clients offers valuable insights.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors personalize client experiences and automate compliance workflows, ultimately leading to stronger client relationships and increased operational efficiency. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.