Benjamin Chow Navigates Wash Sale Rules, Saves Client $65K

Benjamin Chow Navigates Wash Sale Rules, Saves Client $65K

Executive Summary

A high-net-worth client of Benjamin Chow, a financial advisor at Pacific Gate Capital, inadvertently triggered wash sale rules, resulting in a disallowed loss of $200,000 and an estimated $65,000 increase in their tax liability. Facing potential penalties and a significant tax burden, the client sought Chow's expertise to rectify the situation. Chow meticulously identified the wash sales, adjusted the cost basis, and strategically re-established positions outside the prohibited 30-day window, ultimately saving the client $65,000 and ensuring compliance.

The Challenge

Mr. Davis, a successful entrepreneur and client of Pacific Gate Capital, actively manages a portion of his investment portfolio. In late 2023, seeking to strategically harvest losses to offset capital gains, Mr. Davis sold several blocks of stock in technology companies. However, unaware of the intricate details of the wash sale rule, he repurchased substantially similar securities within the 30-day window surrounding the sales.

Specifically, Mr. Davis sold $500,000 worth of Company ABC stock at a loss of $120,000. He then repurchased $400,000 worth of Company ABC stock 25 days later, believing he had satisfied the 30-day waiting period. Similarly, he sold $300,000 of Company XYZ stock at a loss of $80,000 and repurchased $250,000 of it within 15 days.

Upon receiving his 1099-B form, Mr. Davis was shocked to discover that the $200,000 loss ($120,000 + $80,000) was disallowed due to the wash sale rule. This disallowed loss meant his taxable income increased by $200,000, translating to an estimated $65,000 increase in federal income tax liability (assuming a combined federal and state capital gains tax rate of approximately 32.5%). This did not include potential penalties and interest for underpayment of estimated taxes. The situation was further complicated by the fact that Mr. Davis strongly believed in the long-term potential of both Company ABC and Company XYZ and wanted to maintain exposure to these companies in his portfolio. He needed a strategy that would rectify the wash sale issue, minimize his tax burden, and align with his long-term investment objectives.

The Approach

Benjamin Chow understood that addressing the wash sale issue required a meticulous and strategic approach. He broke down the problem into several key steps:

1. Identification and Verification: Chow began by thoroughly reviewing Mr. Davis's brokerage statements and trade confirmations to precisely identify all wash sales. This involved cross-referencing sale dates with repurchase dates within a 30-day window. He used tax reporting software to confirm the brokerage's wash sale identification.

2. Cost Basis Adjustment: Once the wash sales were confirmed, Chow carefully calculated the adjusted cost basis for the repurchased shares. The disallowed loss from the original sale was added to the cost basis of the replacement shares. For example, in the case of Company ABC, the original $500,000 purchase price less $120,000 loss left Mr. Davis with a basis of $380,000 on the $400,000 repurchased. That $120,000 disallowed loss was added to the basis of the replacement shares.

3. Strategic Repositioning: Chow understood that Mr. Davis wanted to maintain exposure to Company ABC and Company XYZ. Therefore, he devised a strategy to re-establish positions outside the 30-day wash sale window while minimizing market disruption. This involved selling the replacement shares and waiting at least 31 days before repurchasing them. To minimize the impact on Mr. Davis' portfolio, Chow explored alternative, but similar, investments within the same sector during the waiting period. This ensured Mr. Davis maintained a similar market exposure without violating the wash sale rules. Examples included purchasing shares of a competing company in the same industry or investing in a sector-specific ETF that included Company ABC and Company XYZ.

4. Tax Planning and Projections: Chow used sophisticated tax planning tools to project the impact of the proposed strategy on Mr. Davis's overall tax liability. This allowed him to fine-tune the strategy and ensure it maximized tax savings while aligning with Mr. Davis's investment goals. The projections included scenarios with and without the corrected wash sale and were presented to Mr. Davis.

5. Communication and Education: Throughout the process, Chow maintained open and transparent communication with Mr. Davis, explaining the complexities of the wash sale rule and the rationale behind the chosen strategy. He educated Mr. Davis on best practices for avoiding wash sales in the future, including utilizing a "tax lot" accounting method and closely monitoring trading activity.

Technical Implementation

The technical aspects of resolving the wash sale issue involved a combination of financial software, data analysis, and custom scripting.

• Brokerage Statement Analysis: Initial identification of potential wash sales relied on carefully reviewing Mr. Davis's consolidated brokerage statements, paying close attention to sale and repurchase dates of substantially identical securities.
• Tax Reporting Software Integration: Tax reporting software like Intuit ProConnect Tax Online and Wolters Kluwer CCH ProSystem fx Tax were used to validate wash sale identification and calculate the adjusted cost basis of the repurchased shares. These platforms automatically flag potential wash sales based on transaction data imported from brokerage statements.
• Python Scripting for Automated Analysis: Given the volume of trades and the need for precise calculations, Chow's team leveraged Python scripting to automate the identification and analysis of wash sales. A custom script was developed using libraries like Pandas and NumPy to:
  • Parse the brokerage statements and extract relevant transaction data (sale date, purchase date, ticker symbol, quantity, price).
  • Identify potential wash sales by comparing sale and repurchase dates within a 30-day window for the same ticker symbol.
  • Calculate the disallowed loss and the adjusted cost basis for the repurchased shares based on IRS regulations.
  • Generate a summary report of all identified wash sales, the disallowed losses, and the adjusted cost basis.
• Sector-Specific ETF Research: When repositioning Mr. Davis's investments, Chow utilized financial data platforms like Bloomberg Terminal and FactSet to research alternative investment options, such as sector-specific ETFs. These platforms allowed him to identify ETFs that provided similar exposure to the technology sector while avoiding direct ownership of Company ABC and Company XYZ during the 30-day wash sale window.

Results & ROI

By meticulously addressing the wash sale issue and implementing a strategic repositioning plan, Benjamin Chow delivered significant financial benefits for Mr. Davis.

• Tax Savings: The primary benefit was the recovery of the disallowed loss, resulting in $65,000 in tax savings. This was achieved by properly accounting for the wash sales and re-establishing the positions outside the prohibited window, allowing Mr. Davis to deduct the losses on his tax return.
• Avoided Penalties: By proactively addressing the wash sale issue, Mr. Davis avoided potential penalties and interest for underpayment of estimated taxes. The IRS can impose penalties for underpaying taxes, especially when a significant portion of income is unreported.
• Portfolio Optimization: The strategic repositioning allowed Mr. Davis to maintain exposure to the technology sector while adhering to tax regulations. By investing in sector-specific ETFs during the 30-day window, he minimized market disruption and ensured his portfolio remained aligned with his investment objectives.
• Enhanced Financial Literacy: Mr. Davis gained a better understanding of wash sale rules and best practices for avoiding them in the future. This increased financial literacy will empower him to make more informed investment decisions and optimize his tax planning strategy.
• Quantifiable ROI: The $65,000 in tax savings represented a significant return on the advisory fees paid to Pacific Gate Capital. This demonstrated the value of expert financial advice and the importance of proactive tax planning.

Key Takeaways

Here are key takeaways for other RIAs and wealth managers:

1. Proactive Client Education: Educate clients about wash sale rules, especially those who actively manage their own portfolios. Provide clear examples and explain the potential consequences of triggering these rules.
2. Thorough Review of Brokerage Statements: Regularly review clients' brokerage statements to identify potential wash sales. Implement automated tools and processes to streamline this review and ensure accuracy.
3. Strategic Repositioning Options: Develop strategies for repositioning investments after a wash sale while minimizing market disruption and adhering to tax regulations. Consider alternative investment options, such as sector-specific ETFs, to maintain market exposure during the 30-day window.
4. Utilize Technology: Employ tax planning software and custom scripting to automate the identification and analysis of wash sales. This will improve efficiency, accuracy, and scalability.
5. Communicate Clearly and Transparently: Maintain open and transparent communication with clients throughout the process, explaining the complexities of wash sale rules and the rationale behind the chosen strategy.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors identify tax opportunities and optimize portfolios with greater speed and accuracy. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.