Achieving 95% Email Archiving Compliance for Santos Financial

Achieving 95% Email Archiving Compliance for Santos Financial

Executive Summary

Santos Financial, a rapidly growing Registered Investment Advisor (RIA) firm, faced significant challenges in maintaining comprehensive and compliant email archiving. Inconsistent practices and a lack of centralized control exposed them to regulatory scrutiny and potential data loss. Golden Door Asset partnered with Santos Financial to implement a robust, cloud-based email archiving solution, resulting in a 95% compliance rate and a 50-hour reduction in quarterly e-discovery efforts, ensuring data security and regulatory adherence.

The Challenge

Santos Financial manages over $350 million in assets for high-net-worth individuals and families. As a fiduciary, the firm is subject to strict regulatory oversight from the SEC and FINRA, requiring meticulous record-keeping, including the archiving of all business-related email communications. Prior to implementing a dedicated solution, Santos Financial relied on a decentralized approach to email archiving, with individual advisors responsible for maintaining their own records. This resulted in several critical problems:

• Incomplete Archiving: A spot audit revealed that approximately 30% of business-related emails were not being consistently archived. This included critical communications regarding investment recommendations, client agreements, and trade confirmations. A failure to produce these records during a regulatory audit could have resulted in substantial fines, estimated at $10,000 per missing document.
• Data Silos: Emails were scattered across individual inboxes, personal computers, and legacy servers, making it difficult to locate and retrieve information efficiently. This made responding to regulatory requests time-consuming and expensive. E-discovery requests were taking an average of 60 hours per quarter to fulfill.
• Compliance Risk: The inconsistent application of retention policies exposed Santos Financial to potential legal and regulatory liabilities. For example, some advisors were deleting emails prematurely, while others were retaining them indefinitely, exceeding the firm's stated retention policy of seven years. This discrepancy created a significant compliance risk and potential for regulatory action.
• Security Vulnerabilities: The reliance on individual devices and personal archives increased the risk of data breaches and unauthorized access to sensitive client information. The firm estimated that a single data breach could result in a loss of client trust and assets under management, potentially costing them upwards of $1 million.
• Inefficient E-Discovery: The cumbersome process of collecting and reviewing emails for e-discovery consumed significant internal resources. Employees were spending an average of 60 hours per quarter compiling information for legal and regulatory requests. The cost of this inefficiency was estimated at $7,500 per quarter, based on the average hourly rate of the employees involved.

These challenges highlighted the urgent need for a comprehensive and centralized email archiving solution to ensure compliance, protect client data, and streamline operations.

The Approach

Golden Door Asset worked closely with Santos Financial's compliance team to develop and implement a tailored email archiving solution. The approach involved a multi-phased strategy:

1. Needs Assessment and Requirements Gathering: Golden Door Asset conducted a thorough assessment of Santos Financial's existing email infrastructure, compliance requirements, and business needs. This included interviews with key stakeholders, a review of existing policies and procedures, and an analysis of email traffic patterns. The goal was to understand the specific challenges and identify the key requirements for a successful email archiving solution.

2. Solution Selection: Based on the needs assessment, Golden Door Asset recommended Proofpoint Enterprise Archive, a leading cloud-based email archiving platform. Proofpoint was selected for its robust features, scalability, and compliance capabilities, including:

   • Automated Archiving: Automatically captures and indexes all inbound and outbound emails.
   • Granular Retention Policies: Allows for the creation of custom retention policies based on email content, sender, and recipient.
   • Advanced Search Capabilities: Provides powerful search tools to quickly locate and retrieve specific emails.
   • Secure Storage: Stores archived emails in a secure, compliant cloud environment.

3. Policy Development: Golden Door Asset collaborated with Santos Financial's compliance team to develop comprehensive email retention policies that aligned with regulatory requirements and best practices. These policies defined the types of emails that needed to be archived, the length of time they needed to be retained, and the procedures for deleting emails when they were no longer needed. A key policy was the standardized 7-year retention period for all client-related communication, as mandated by regulatory bodies.

4. Implementation and Configuration: Golden Door Asset implemented Proofpoint Enterprise Archive and configured it to meet Santos Financial's specific requirements. This included:

   • Integrating the archiving solution with Santos Financial's existing email server (Microsoft Exchange).
   • Configuring granular retention policies based on email content, sender, and recipient.
   • Setting up user access controls to ensure only authorized personnel could access archived emails.
   • Implementing data encryption to protect archived emails from unauthorized access.

5. Training and Support: Golden Door Asset provided comprehensive training to Santos Financial's employees on how to use the new email archiving solution. This included training on how to search for archived emails, how to apply retention policies, and how to comply with regulatory requirements. Ongoing support was also provided to address any questions or issues that arose.

Technical Implementation

The technical implementation of Proofpoint Enterprise Archive involved several key steps:

• Integration with Microsoft Exchange: Proofpoint Enterprise Archive was seamlessly integrated with Santos Financial's existing Microsoft Exchange email server using SMTP journaling. This ensured that all inbound and outbound emails were automatically captured and indexed without disrupting the normal flow of email traffic.
• Granular Retention Policy Configuration: Retention policies were configured based on email content and sender using keyword filtering and sender domain analysis. For example, any email containing the keywords "investment recommendation," "trade confirmation," or "client agreement" was automatically assigned a 7-year retention period. Emails from specific sender domains (e.g., @brokeragefirm.com) were also automatically archived and retained for the same period.
• Advanced Search Indexing: Proofpoint Enterprise Archive automatically indexes all archived emails, allowing users to quickly and easily search for specific emails using keywords, sender, recipient, date range, and other criteria. The indexing process supports full-text search, enabling users to find emails even if they don't know the exact wording.
• Secure Data Storage: Archived emails are stored in Proofpoint's secure, compliant cloud environment, which is designed to meet the stringent security and compliance requirements of the financial services industry. The data is encrypted both in transit and at rest, protecting it from unauthorized access.
• Role-Based Access Control: Access to archived emails is controlled using role-based access control, ensuring that only authorized personnel can access sensitive information. Different roles were defined for compliance officers, legal counsel, and individual advisors, each with specific permissions.
• Automated Legal Hold: The solution included automated legal hold capabilities. When litigation or regulatory investigation arose, identified emails could be placed on legal hold to prevent deletion and preserve them for e-discovery.

Results & ROI

The implementation of Proofpoint Enterprise Archive delivered significant benefits to Santos Financial:

• Increased Compliance Rate: Email archiving compliance increased from 70% to 95%, significantly reducing the risk of regulatory fines and penalties.
• Reduced E-Discovery Time: The time required to fulfill e-discovery requests decreased from 60 hours per quarter to just 10 hours per quarter, resulting in a 50-hour reduction. This represents an 83% time saving.
• Cost Savings: The reduction in e-discovery time translated into significant cost savings. Based on the average hourly rate of the employees involved, Santos Financial saved an estimated $6,250 per quarter, or $25,000 per year.
• Improved Data Security: The secure, cloud-based archiving solution reduced the risk of data breaches and unauthorized access to sensitive client information.
• Enhanced Audit Trails: The solution provided a comprehensive audit trail of all email archiving activities, making it easier to demonstrate compliance to regulators.
• Improved Productivity: By streamlining the email archiving and e-discovery processes, Santos Financial's employees were able to focus on more strategic tasks, improving overall productivity.
• Reduced Storage Costs: Centralized archiving reduced duplicated emails and saved valuable local server space. It's estimated that annual storage costs were reduced by 15% per employee, representing a savings of $1,500 company-wide.

Key Takeaways

For other Registered Investment Advisors (RIAs) and wealth managers looking to improve their email archiving compliance, consider the following:

1. Prioritize Compliance: Implement a comprehensive email archiving solution to ensure compliance with SEC and FINRA regulations. Don't underestimate the potential cost of non-compliance.
2. Centralize Archiving: Move away from decentralized archiving practices and implement a centralized solution that provides consistent control and visibility over all email communications.
3. Automate Retention Policies: Configure granular retention policies to ensure that emails are retained for the required period and deleted when they are no longer needed. Automation is critical for ensuring consistency.
4. Invest in Training: Provide comprehensive training to employees on how to use the email archiving solution and comply with regulatory requirements. Ensure ongoing support is available to address any questions or issues.
5. Regularly Audit Processes: Conduct regular audits of your email archiving processes to identify any gaps or weaknesses and take corrective action.

About Golden Door Asset

Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors optimize client portfolios with data-driven insights. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.