$340K Tax Savings: Proactive Tax Planning Boosts AUM
Executive Summary
Rossi Family Office Services recognized that their clients, despite enjoying investment gains, were leaving significant money on the table due to suboptimal tax planning. By implementing a proactive tax strategy encompassing regular reviews, strategic asset location, and tax-loss harvesting, Rossi Family Office Services generated $340,000 in tax savings for their clients. This demonstrable value resulted in increased client satisfaction, enhanced AUM, and a surge in client referrals.
The Challenge
Rossi Family Office Services serves high-net-worth individuals and families, many of whom had previously relied on reactive tax preparation services. While compliant with tax laws, these approaches failed to capitalize on available tax-saving opportunities, ultimately hindering their clients' long-term financial goals.
Specifically, clients faced several key challenges:
- Suboptimal Asset Location: Many clients held taxable investments in accounts that should have been tax-advantaged, and vice-versa. For instance, one client, the Miller family, held $500,000 in high-dividend stocks within a taxable brokerage account, generating approximately $25,000 in qualified dividend income annually, subject to potentially high tax rates depending on their overall income bracket. This resulted in an estimated $3,750 - $5,000 in unnecessary taxes each year (assuming a 15%-20% qualified dividend tax rate).
- Missed Tax-Loss Harvesting Opportunities: Clients were unaware of the potential to offset capital gains by strategically selling underperforming investments to realize losses. A client, Mr. Johnson, had unrealized losses of $80,000 in his portfolio but wasn't actively managing these losses for tax benefits. Failing to harvest these losses meant missing the opportunity to offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year, or to offset capital gains taxes on realized gains elsewhere in the portfolio.
- Lack of Proactive Tax Planning Integration: Tax planning was treated as a separate, annual exercise rather than an integrated component of the overall financial plan. Consequently, investment decisions were made without considering the potential tax implications, leading to missed opportunities for tax optimization. For example, a client, the Davis Family Trust, made a $100,000 charitable contribution directly from a taxable account when donating appreciated stock would have provided a double benefit: a charitable deduction at fair market value and avoidance of capital gains taxes on the appreciation.
- Complexity with Qualified Opportunity Zones (QOZ): Some clients were interested in QOZ investments but lacked clarity on the intricate rules and regulations surrounding them. Improperly structuring a QOZ investment could negate potential tax benefits or even result in penalties. One potential investor was considering rolling over $200,000 of capital gains into a QOZ fund but wasn't aware of the strict 180-day deadline, the potential for inclusion events, or the complexities of exiting the investment.
The cost of these missed opportunities was significant, impacting clients' net worth and hindering their ability to achieve their financial objectives.
The Approach
Rossi Family Office Services adopted a comprehensive, proactive tax planning approach that integrated tax considerations into every aspect of financial planning. The framework included:
- Initial Tax Diagnostic Review: A thorough review of clients' prior-year tax returns, current-year income projections, and investment portfolios was conducted to identify potential tax-saving opportunities. This involved gathering comprehensive financial data, including W-2s, 1099s, brokerage statements, and real estate information.
- Strategic Asset Location Optimization: Assets were strategically allocated across different account types (taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-exempt) to minimize tax liabilities. High-growth assets and those generating ordinary income were prioritized for placement in tax-advantaged accounts, while tax-efficient investments were held in taxable accounts. This involved a detailed analysis of the client's marginal tax bracket, investment time horizon, and risk tolerance.
- Active Tax-Loss Harvesting: Rossi Family Office Services implemented a systematic process for identifying and harvesting tax losses throughout the year. This involved monitoring portfolio performance, identifying underperforming assets, and strategically selling them to realize losses, which were then used to offset capital gains or reduce ordinary income. A "wash sale" rule monitoring system was implemented to prevent unintentional violations.
- Tax-Efficient Investment Strategies: Investment strategies were tailored to minimize tax liabilities, such as utilizing tax-managed mutual funds and ETFs, avoiding frequent trading, and implementing a buy-and-hold approach. Specific attention was paid to minimizing distributions of capital gains within investment funds.
- Charitable Giving Strategies: Clients were advised on tax-efficient charitable giving strategies, such as donating appreciated securities instead of cash, establishing donor-advised funds, and utilizing qualified charitable distributions (QCDs) from IRAs.
- Ongoing Monitoring and Review: Tax plans were reviewed and adjusted regularly to reflect changes in clients' financial circumstances, tax laws, and investment performance. This included quarterly reviews of portfolio performance and annual tax planning meetings with clients.
- Education and Communication: Clients were educated on the importance of tax planning and kept informed about tax-saving opportunities. Rossi Family Office Services provided regular updates on tax law changes and their potential impact on clients' financial plans.
Technical Implementation
Rossi Family Office Services leveraged technology and integrated its systems to streamline the tax planning process:
- Holistiplan Integration: Holistiplan was utilized to analyze clients' tax returns and identify potential tax-saving opportunities. The software's ability to quickly and accurately analyze tax data enabled Rossi Family Office Services to pinpoint areas where clients could reduce their tax burden. Specific modules used included the Roth Conversion Analyzer, the Social Security Optimization tool, and the Capital Gains Projection Worksheet.
- Portfolio Management System Integration: The portfolio management system (e.g., Orion Advisor Tech, Black Diamond) was integrated with Holistiplan to enable seamless data transfer and facilitate tax-loss harvesting. This integration allowed Rossi Family Office Services to monitor portfolio performance in real-time and identify opportunities to realize losses. Custom reports were created to track unrealized gains and losses on a tax-lot basis.
- Tax-Efficient Investment Strategies: Investments were carefully selected based on their tax efficiency. For example, using municipal bonds for taxable accounts to reduce taxable income. The after-tax returns were calculated using the client's effective tax rate, which was derived from Holistiplan.
- Tax-Loss Harvesting Calculation: The tax-loss harvesting strategy involved calculating the potential tax savings from realizing losses. This calculation considered the client's capital gains tax rate, ordinary income tax rate, and the amount of available capital losses. The maximum $3,000 of ordinary income offset was also considered.
- Asset Location Optimization Calculation: The asset location strategy involved calculating the after-tax return of different asset classes in different account types. This calculation considered the client's dividend tax rate, capital gains tax rate, and the tax-deferred or tax-exempt status of the account.
- Data Security: Data security protocols were implemented to protect client information, including encryption, multi-factor authentication, and regular security audits. The data security measures complied with SEC regulations.
Results & ROI
The proactive tax planning approach implemented by Rossi Family Office Services yielded significant results:
- $340,000 in Tax Savings: Clients collectively realized $340,000 in tax savings in the first year of implementation. This was achieved through a combination of strategic asset location, tax-loss harvesting, and tax-efficient investment strategies.
- Increased Client Satisfaction: Client satisfaction scores increased by 25% following the implementation of the proactive tax planning approach. Clients expressed greater confidence in Rossi Family Office Services' ability to manage their wealth effectively.
- Client Referrals: Client referrals increased by 40% as satisfied clients recommended Rossi Family Office Services to their friends and family. This growth significantly reduced the firm's marketing costs and improved brand awareness.
- AUM Growth: Assets under management (AUM) increased by 15% in the first year, driven by client referrals and increased client retention. The demonstrated value of the tax planning services attracted new clients and encouraged existing clients to consolidate more of their assets with Rossi Family Office Services.
- Illustrative Example: The Miller family, mentioned earlier, realized approximately $4,000 per year in dividend tax savings by shifting their high-dividend stocks to a tax-advantaged account. Mr. Johnson was able to offset $3,000 of ordinary income in the current tax year, and carry forward $77,000 in capital losses to future years, thanks to tax-loss harvesting.
Key Takeaways
For other RIAs and wealth managers, the following insights can be gleaned from this case study:
- Proactive Tax Planning is a Differentiator: Offering proactive tax planning as an integral part of your services can differentiate you from competitors and attract high-net-worth clients.
- Technology Enables Efficiency: Utilizing tax planning software and integrating it with your portfolio management system can streamline the tax planning process and improve efficiency.
- Quantify Your Value: Demonstrating the tangible benefits of your services through quantifiable metrics, such as tax savings, can increase client satisfaction and drive referrals.
- Continuous Monitoring is Essential: Tax planning is not a one-time event; it requires ongoing monitoring and adjustments to ensure clients are maximizing their tax-saving opportunities.
- Client Education Builds Trust: Educating clients about tax planning strategies can build trust and foster stronger relationships, leading to increased retention and referrals.
About Golden Door Asset
Golden Door Asset builds AI-powered intelligence tools for RIAs. Our platform helps advisors unlock deeper client insights and automate complex financial planning tasks, freeing up time for personalized client relationships. Visit our tools to see how we can help your practice.